환경영향평가 관련 행정소송에서의 주요 쟁점 (Major Issues in Administrative Litigation Related to the Environmental Impact Assessment)

이영수 (YoungSoo Lee); 최현진 (HyunJin Choi); 지민규 (MinGyu Ji); 강유진 (EuGene Kang); 최준규 (JunKyu Choi)

doi:10.14249/eia.2025.34.6.586

Major Issues in Administrative Litigation Related to the Environmental Impact Assessment

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment
Abbr : J EIA
2025, 34(6), pp.586~602
DOI : 10.14249/eia.2025.34.6.586
Publisher : Korean Society Of Environmental Impact Assessment
Research Area : Engineering > Environmental Engineering
Received : November 20, 2025
Accepted : December 3, 2025
Published : December 30, 2025

YoungSoo Lee ¹, HyunJin Choi ¹, MinGyu Ji ¹, EuGene Kang ¹, JunKyu Choi ²

¹한국환경연구원
²(주)새봄

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Social conflicts surrounding projects subject to environmental impact assessment (EIA)have continued, and disputes have arisen concerning the procedures and contents of the EIA process. In response, an analysis of administrative litigation and administrative trial cases related to EIA wasconducted to explore measures for reducing unproductive social conflicts in advance. As a result,seven key issues were identified: ① Disposition of EIA consultations, ② Determining whether a projectis subject to EIA, ③ Plaintiff eligibility, ④ Non-compliance with consultation procedure, ⑤ Inadequateevaluation, ⑥ Abuse or deviation of discretionary power by the approving authority, and ⑦ Effectivenessof EIA consultation. By identifying the details of these issues and taking them into account during theEIA process, unnecessary conflicts can be reduced.

KEYWORDS

Social Conflicts, Administrative Litigation, Administrative Trial, 7 Major Issues

Journal Copyright Policy

No CCL information provided

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2025 are currently being built.

[other] / 2023 / 공사중지명령처분취소, 2023.7.18. 선고, 2022누13747

[other] / 2023 / 실시계획인가처분등 무효확인청구의 소, 2023.2.9. 선고, 2021구합12886

[other] / 2023 / 업무정지처분취소, 2023.2.2. 선고, 2019두36025

[other] / 2022 / 공공주택지구지정취소, 2022.5.12. 선고, 2021누35829

[other] / 2021 / 도시계획시설(공원)사업(삼매봉공원 외 5개소) 실시계획작성처분취소, 2021.10.5. 선고, 2020구합 5984

[other] / 2021 / 손해배상, 2021.8.12. 선고, 2015다208320

[other] / 2021 / 남양주왕숙공공주택지구지정처분취소청구의소, 2021.8.10. 선고, 2020구합51204

[other] / 2021 / 건축허가거부처분취소

[other] / 2021 / 폐기물처리 사업계획의 부적합 통보처분취소, 2021. 6.3. 선고, 2020구합101743

[other] / 2021 / 환경영향평가 협의결과 취소청구, 2021.4.13. 재결, 2021-1516

[other] / 2020 / 환경영향평가 부동의 협의의견 통보 취소청구, 2020. 12.29. 재결, 2019-24121

[other] / 2020 / 소규모 환경영향평가 부동의 협의의견 취소청구의 소, 2020.6.4. 선고, 2019구합1316

[other] / 2019 / 국립공원계획변경처분 무효확인등, 2019.1.31. 선고, 2015구합13079

[other] / 2017 / 토석채취허가신청반려처분취소, 2017.11.22. 선고, 2017구합103558

[other] / 2015 / 하천공사시행계획취소, 2015.12.10. 선고, 2012두6322

[other] / 2015 / 하천공사시행계획취소, 2015.12.10. 선고, 2011두32515

[other] / 2015 / 개발제한구역행위(건축)허가취소, 2015.8.20. 선고, 2013누20594

[other] / 2014 / 도로구역결정변경청구, 2014.12.12. 선고, 2014누21271

[other] / 2014 / 도시관리계획무효확인등, 2014.7.24. 선고, 2012두4616

[other] / 2014 / 국방·군사시설사업실시계획승인고시처분무효확인및취소, 2014.3.13. 선고, 2012두1006

[other] / 2014 / 분뇨및쓰레기처리시설허가취소, 2014.2.27. 선고, 2013 두3283

[other] / 2014 / 분뇨및쓰레기처리시설허가취소, 2014.2.27. 선고, 2011 두14074

[other] / 2013 / 항만공사시행처분무효등, 2013.2.20. 선고, 2012구합 687

[other] / 2012 / 국방·군사시설사업실시계획승인처분무효확인등, 2012.7.5. 선고, 2011두19239, 전원합의체 판결

[other] / 2012 / 블랙스톤골프장조성사업실시계획승인고시취소, 2012.1.26. 선고, 2010누1063

[other] / 2011 / 집행정지, 2011.4.21. 선고, 2010무111 전원합의체 결정

[other] / 2010 / 집단에너지 사업허가처분취소, 2010.8.19. 선고, 2008 누32609, 2008누32616(병합)

[other] / 2010 / 공사계획인가처분취소등, 2010.4.23. 선고, 2008구합 29038

[other] / 2010 / 공장설립승인취소, 2010.4.15. 선고, 2007두16127

[other] / 2009 / 개발사업시행승인처분취소, 2009.9.24. 선고, 2009두 2825

[other] / 2009 / 도로구역결정처분취소, 2009.4.23. 선고, 2007두13159

[other] / 2007 / 국토이용개발계획변경결정취소등, 2007.4.26. 선고, 2003누1270

[other] / 2006 / 공장설립승인처분취소, 2006.12.22. 선고, 2006두14001

[other] / 2006 / 국방군사시설사업실시계획승인처분무효확인, 2006. 6.30. 선고, 2005두14363

[other] / 2006 / 공사착공금지가처분, 2006.6.2. 자, 2004마1148 결정

[other] / 2006 / 사업실시계획승인취소, 2006.4.13. 선고, 2005구합1153

[other] / 2006 / 정부조치계획취소등, 2006.3.16. 선고, 2006두330 전원합의체 판결

[other] / 2006 / 신항만배후철도건설실시 승인취소청구, 삼랑진·진주복선전철화사업 일부구간실시계획 승인취소청구, 2006.2.16. 선고, 2005구합1853, 2955

[other] / 2005 / 폐기물처리시설입지결정및고시처분취소, 2005.5.12. 선고, 2004두14229

[other] / 2005 / 쓰레기 소각장 입지지역결정고시취소청구, 2005.3.11. 선고, 2003두13489

[other] / 2004 / 납골당허가처분무효확인, 2004.12.9. 선고, 2003두12073

[other] / 2001 / 온천조성사업시행허가처분취소, 2001.7.27. 선고, 99두 8589

[other] / 2001 / 공원사업시행허가처분취소재결취소, 2001.7.27. 선고, 99두5092

[other] / 2001 / 경부고속철도서울차량기지정비창건설사업실시계획승인처분취소, 2001.6.29. 선고, 99두9902

[other] / 1998 / 부지사전승인처분취소, 1998.9.4. 선고, 97누19588

[other] / 1998 / 발전소건설승인처분취소, 1998.9.2. 선고, 97누19571

[other] / 1998 / 공원사업시행허가처분취소, 1998.4.24. 선고, 97누3286

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment 2025 KCI Impact Factor : 0.63

Major Issues in Administrative Litigation Related to the Environmental Impact Assessment

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Journal Copyright Policy

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2025 are currently being built.

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment 2025 KCI Impact Factor : 0.63

Major Issues in Administrative Litigation Related to the Environmental Impact Assessment

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Journal Copyright Policy

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (47) * References for papers published after 2025 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2025 are currently being built.