@article{ART001650194},
author={Jinkyu Kim},
title={The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs},
journal={Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies},
issn={1229-0521},
year={2012},
volume={18},
number={1},
pages={60-81},
doi={10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60}
TY - JOUR
AU - Jinkyu Kim
TI - The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs
JO - Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies
PY - 2012
VL - 18
IS - 1
PB - Korean Society of Old Testament Studies
SP - 60
EP - 81
SN - 1229-0521
AB - The goal of this study is to find out the fittest Korean word for the Hebrew word ‘maskil.’ This study narrowly focuses on the translation of ‘maskil’ (hiphil, participle, absolute form) in the Book of Proverbs. There are only six cases of this form in Prov (10:5; 10:19; 14:35; 15:24; 17:2; 19:14), besides two cases with a preposition (16:20; 21:12). The best translation for this word would be ‘prudence/prudent’ as many English Bible versions rendered this way. (The authoritative English translations such as ESV, RSV, NRSV, and NASB were selected to compare with Korean versions.) However, New Korean Revised Version (NKRV) never uses this term for ‘maskil’ in this form. NKRV largely translates this word into ‘widom/wise.’BDB and TDOT offer the best translation for the definition of ‘maskil’ in context. BDB provides six definitions for the hiphil form of ‘sakal’ as follows: (1) “look at,” (2) “give attention to, consider, ponder,” (3) “have insight, comprehension,” (4) “cause to consider, give insight, teach,” (5) “act circumspectly, prudently,” (6) “prosper, have success” (BDB, #7919). BDB pinpoints the definition of the substantive form of ‘makil’ belongs to the fifth category among these (Prov 10:5, 19; 14:35; 15:24; 17:2; 19:14; Job 22:2). TDOT also gives a similar definition for the hiphil form of ‘sakal’ when used absolutely. It means “be reasonable, act reasonably,” “be prudent, act prudently” (TDOT 14:118). Other dictionaries such as NIDOTTE, THAT, and TWOT do not give such a precise definition for ‘maskil’ in the hiphil substantive form. Above all, B. Waltke gives the most inspiring definition for 'maskil.' In his excellent commentaries on Proverbs, he defines “being prudent” is the most important meaning for ‘maskil.’ Though the Korean word for ‘prudence’ (shinjung) may not be a precise word for ‘maskil’ because of the slight differences of the semantic fields between two languages (however, it is unavoidable in many cases), but this word is its fittest term for 'maskil' among Korean wisdom-related words.
KW - maskil;prudence;wisdom;hokma;Proverbs
DO - 10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
ER -
Jinkyu Kim. (2012). The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs. Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies, 18(1), 60-81.
Jinkyu Kim. 2012, "The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs", Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies, vol.18, no.1 pp.60-81. Available from: doi:10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim "The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs" Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies 18.1 pp.60-81 (2012) : 60.
Jinkyu Kim. The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs. 2012; 18(1), 60-81. Available from: doi:10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim. "The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs" Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies 18, no.1 (2012) : 60-81.doi: 10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim. The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs. Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies, 18(1), 60-81. doi: 10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim. The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs. Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies. 2012; 18(1) 60-81. doi: 10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim. The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs. 2012; 18(1), 60-81. Available from: doi:10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
Jinkyu Kim. "The Issue of the Translation of ‘maskil' in Proverbs" Korean Journal of Old Testament Studies 18, no.1 (2012) : 60-81.doi: 10.24333/jkots.2012.18.1.60
