Informatization Policy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 4.08
-
pISSN : 1598-3498
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/nia
KJCKorea
Journal Central
China's strategies for ICT standards
- Informatization Policy
- Abbr : 정보화정책
- 2008, 15(4), pp.55-68
- Publisher : NIA
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy
Heejin Lee 1, 오상조 2
1연세대학교
2동양미래대학
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Since China’s accession to WTO in 2001, standards have emerged as an effective means to protect and promote domestic industries, especially in the ICT sector. China develops its own standards in many areas of the ICT sector, and intends to establish each of them as an international standard. Despite the significance of understanding the impacts of these standard setting attempts on the ICT industry in Korea, there is little research in this area.
This paper investigates China’s attempts to set up ICT standards. Three standards (WAPI, TD-SCDMA and AVS) are examined to find similarities and differences in the processes of their development and standardization. Techno-nationalism and techno-globalism are used to identify the patterns of China’s ICT standards strategy. In contrast with a previous study which concludes China’s standards policy as‘ neo-techno-nationalism’, this paper reveals that each case has a distinguished orientation in terms of techno-nationalism and techno-gloabalism: WAPI is aligned with techno-nationalism, TD-SCDMA with technoglobalism, and AVS with techno-hybrids or neo-techno-nationalism. Implications for the Korean ICT industry are discussed in the context of Korean ICT firms’entrance to the Chinese market, ICT standards in coming FTAs, and standards wars where Korean ICT firms are increasingly involved.
Statistics
-
308 Viewed
-
2 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[other]
동아일보
/ 2007
/ 경제현장부터 챙긴 원자바오
[other]
동아일보
/ 2007
/ 한-EU FTA 한국측 협상단 누가 뛰나
[book]
동아일보
/ 2007
/ 글로벌 표준 선택해야 혁신적 아이디어도 날개
[book]
동아일보
/ 2007
/ 초대석:한국,EU와 FTA체결땐 인구 5억 시장 열려
[confproc]
오상조
/ 2006
/ 정보통신 국제표준을 향한 후발 진입자의 전략: 개방성
/ 제2회 정보통신표준화 우수논문집
/ 한국정보통신기술협회
: 125~139
[confproc]
오상조
/ 2005
/ 무선랜 보안표준을 둘러싼 중국과 미국의 표준 전쟁: 한국의 세계 표준 전략 및 정책에 주는 시사점
/ 제3회 표준화우수논문 수상논문집
/ 한국표준협회
: 125~157
[book]
전자신문
/ 2008
/ 휴대폰‘위피’탑재의무 없어진다
[book]
조선일보
/ 2003
/ 한국 정부,휴대전화 운영체제 표준화추진 무역 자유화 추세 어긋나
[book]
조선일보
/ 2004
/ 미,휴대전화 표준통산압력
[book]
조선일보
/ 2007
/ 위피없는 휴대폰 곧 출시..가격 더떨어져
[book]
조선일보
/ 2007
/ 노키아 부사장 위피 때문에 한국진출어렵다
[book]
조선일보
/ 2007c
/ 와이브로 세계 표준기술로 등극할듯
[book]
한국경제신문
/ 2008
/ 중국 67조 통신시장 열린다.3G이통면허 발급키로
[book]
한겨레
/ 2007
/ 와이브로 3G표준 채택 여부 8월말 결정
[journal]
Cam-Winget,N.
/ 2003
/ Security flaws in 802.11 data link protocols
/ Communications of the ACM
46(5)
: 35~39
[book]
Chen,K.
/ 2004
/ China will keep pursuing digital standards
/ The Wall Street Journal
[other]
China Daily
/ 2006
/ China Daily (2006). “China’s 3G standard in Korea.”http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/bizchina/2006-09/04/content_680865.htm(검색일: 2006. 11. 05)
[book]
China Internet Information Center News
/ 2003
/ AVS standard developing
[other]
ChinaTechNews.com
/ 2008
/ ChinaTechNews.com (2008). “China Mobile Will Donate TD Mobile Phones To Olympics Organizing Committee.”http://www.chinatechnews.com/2008/04/16/6623-china-mobile-will-donate-td-mobilep h o n e s - t o - o l y m p i c s - o r g a n i z i n g -committee/ (검색일: 2008. 10. 26)
[other]
Chinese Ministry of Information Industry
/ 2006
/ Chinese Ministry of Information Industry (2005). “ Research, Development and Commercialisation of the Third Generation Mobile Telecommunications - TD-SCDMA.” http://www.mii.gov.cn/art/2005/12/30/art_60_4168.html (검색일: 2006. 11. 08)
[other]
Chinese Ministry of Information Industry
/ 2006
/ Chinese Ministry of Information Industry (2006a). “Notice on the Ministry of Information Industry Announcement Regarding the ‘2006 Telecommunications Industry Development Fund Tender Projects’.”http://www.mii.gov.cn/art/2006/06/30/art_80_17189.html (검색일: 2006. 11. 08)
[book]
Chinese Ministry of Information Industry
/ 2006b
/ "Ministry of Information Industry Announced the TD-SCDMA Telecommunications Standard."http://www.mii.gov.cn/art/2006/01/20/art_47_5206
[other]
Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology
/ 2006
/ Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology (2006a). “Ministry of Information Industry Allocated Funds to Support Four Types of Telecommunication Technologies: TD and AVS Are Focus Areas.”http://www.most.gov.cn/kjjr/kjzy/kjxm/200609/t20060915_36074.htm (검색일: 2006. 11. 08)
[other]
Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology
/ 2006
/ Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology (2006b). “Formal Announcement of the Implementation of AVS Standard.”http://www.mii.gov.cn/art/2006/03/09/art_1042_7806.html (검색일: 2006. 11. 08)
[book]
Clendenin,M.
/ 2003
/ China looks inward to cut dependence on foreign IP
/ EBN
[book]
Clendenin,M.
/ 2005
/ WAPI’s promise
/ Electronic Engineering Times, 1360: 4
[book]
Clendenin,M.
/ 2006
/ Chinese A/V codec rises.” Electronic Engineering Times, 1411: 1-2
[journal]
Cromer,Z.
/ 2005
/ China’s WAPI policy: Security measure or trade protectionism
/ Duke Law & Technology Review
18
[other]
Fang, H.D.
/ 2004
/ Fang, H.D., Pan, H.H. & Fu, Z. (2004). “The Many Pressures of WAPI Standard: Can China Take Them? (in Chinese)”http://price.zol.com.cn/article/2004/0428/95632.shtml (검색일: 2004. 10. 30)
[book]
Flynn,L.
/ 2004
/ Intel to miss China deadline on standard for wireless
/ The New York Times. 5월 11일
[other]
Fordahl, M.
/ 2004
/ Fordahl, M. (2004). “Intel Won’t Comply with Chinese Wireless Standards.”http://www.informationweek.com/story/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=18311987 (검색일: (2004. 10. 30)
[book]
Foremski,T.
/ 2004
/ Intel attacks Chinese chip standard
/ Financial Times. 3월 11일
[journal]
Greenstein,S.
/ 1992
/ Invisible hands and visible advisors: An economic interpretation of standardization
/ Journal of the American society for Information Science
43(8)
: 538~549
[journal]
Housley,R.
/ 2003
/ Security problems in 802.11-based networks
/ Communications of the ACM
/ 31-34.
46(5)
: 31~34
[book]
Jen,L.
/ 2003
/ Who will get China’s 3G dowry?
/ IEEE Spectrum
: 16~18
[other]
Kanellos, M.
/ 2004
/ Kanellos, M. (2004). “Divide between U.S. Tech Firms, China - a great wall?”http://aswia.cnet.com/news/industry/0,39037106, 39172654,00.htm (검색일: 2004. 10. 30)
[journal]
Kennedy,S.
/ 2006
/ The political economy of standards coalitions: Explaining China’s involvement in high-tech standards wars
/ Asia Policy
2
: 41~62
[thesis]
Laperrouza,M.
/ 2006
/ China’s Telecommunication Policy-Making in the Context of Trade and Economic Reforms
/ 박사
/ London School of Economics
[journal]
Lee,H.
/ 2008
/ The political economy of standards setting by newcomers: China’s WAPI and South Korea’s WIPI
/ Telecommunications Policy
32
: 662~671
[journal]
Lee,H.
/ 2006
/ A standards war waged by a developing country: Understanding international standard setting from the actor-network perspective
/ Journal of Strategic Information Systems
15
: 177~195
[other]
Lemon, S.
/ 2004
/ Lemon, S. (2004).“ Despite Shelving WAPI, China Stands Firm on Chip Tax.”http://www.infoworld.com/article/04/04/22/Hnshelvin gwapi_1.html (검색일: 2004. 10. 30)
[journal]
Ling,L.
/ 2005
/ Innovation rules
/ Beijing Review
48(46)
: 36~
[book]
Liu,B.
/ 2005a
/ Industrial alliance on AVS on the way
/ China Daily. 4월 18일
[journal]
Montresor,S.
/ 2001
/ Techno-globalism, Techno-nationalism and Technological Systems: Organising the Evidence
/ Technovation
21
: 399~412
[book]
Mu,J.
/ 2005
/ China’s compression choice
/ EDN
: 56~57
[book]
Naughton, B.
/ 2003
/ China in search of a workable model: Technology development in the new millennium in : Crisis and Innovation in Asian Technology
/ Cambridge University Press
: 160~186
[book]
Ostry,S.
/ 1995
/ Technonationalism and Techno-globalism: Conflict and Cooperation
/ The Brookings Institution
[other]
Palowireless
/ 2006
/ Palowireless (2006). “TD-SCDMA - China’s Chance.”www.palowireless.com/3g/docs/ TD-SCDMA-China.pdf. (검색일: 2006. 05. 30)
[other]
Perkins Coie
/ 2004a
/ Perkins Coie (2004a). “China Legal Highlights.” http://www.perkinscoie.com/content/ren/updates/china/january2004.htm (검색일: 2004. 10. 29)
[other]
Perkins Coie
/ 2004b
/ Perkins Coie (2004b). “China Legal Highlights.” http://www.perkinscoie.com/content/ren/updates/china/june2004.htm (검색일: 2004. 10. 29)
[book]
Qu,P.
/ 2005
/ The new standardbearer
/ IEEE Spectrum
: 49~52
[book]
Reuters
/ 2004
/ US Has No Plan for WTO Case on China Wi-Fi Rules
/ as cited in Suttmeier and Yao
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2002
/ Calls for Chinese audio standard
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2004a
/ China Stands Hard on WAPI
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2004
/ China to Have Homemade AVS
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2005
/ China,US Reach Agreement on WAPI
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2005
/ Skyworth to accelerate drawing AVS audio standard
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2005
/ AVS high definition TV to come into market in October
[book]
SinoCast China Business Daily News
/ 2006
/ Motorola Supports AVS
[book]
Standardisation Administrative Commission of China
/ 2004
/ China’s Technology Standards Development Strategy Research: Final Report
/ Consultation Draft
[book]
Suttmeier,R.
/ 2004
/ China’s Post- WTO Technology Policy: Standards, Software and the Changing Nature of Techno-Nationalism
/ The National Bureau of Asian Research: Special Report, 7
[other]
TD-SCDMA Forum
/ 2006
/ TD-SCDMA Forum (2006). The Milestone of TDSCDMA (2000-2005) www.tdscdma-forum.org/EN/resources/see.asp?id=6 (검색일: 2006. 06. 03)
[other]
3GPP
/ 2006
/ 3GPP (2006). About 3GPP. www.3gpp.org/About/about.htm (검색일: 2006. 06. 05)
[other]
TradingMarkets.com
/ 2008a
/ TradingMarkets.com (2008a). “China Unicom Kicks off WCDMA Equipment Procurement.” www.tradingmarkets.com/.site/news/Stock %20News/1928653/ (검색일: 2008. 10. 26)
[other]
TradingMarkets.com
/ 2008b
/ TradingMarkets.com (2008b). “China Telecom to put 3G into trial operation at the yearend.” http://www.tradingmarkets.com/.site/news/Stock%20News/1968045/ (검색일: 2008. 10. 26)
[book]
USRT (United States Trade Representative)
/ 2007a
/ Trade Facts
/ Free trade with Korea-Brief summary of the agreement
[book]
USRT(United States Trade Representative)
/ 2007b
/ Trade Facts
/ Free trade with Korea-Summary of the KORUS FTA
[journal]
Weber,S.
/ 2005
/ A power play that almost paid off
/ Across the Board
42(2)
: 42~43
[book]
World Trade Organisation
/ 2004
/ The WTO In Brief
[other]
Yamada, A.
/ 2000
/ Yamada, A. (2000). “Neo-Techno-Nationalism: How and Why It Grows.” Columbia International Affairs Online. http://www.ciaonet.org/isa/yaa01/ (검색일: 2005. 01. 03)
[book]
Yan,L.
/ 2005
/ ISO meeting fails to back WAPI standard
/ China Daily. 2월 25일