Informatization Policy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 4.08
-
pISSN : 1598-3498
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/nia
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Study on the Failure Factors of Popular Use of International Domain Names (IDNs): Focusing on the International Standardization Process
- Informatization Policy
- Abbr : 정보화정책
- 2016, 23(3), pp.43-63
- DOI : 10.22693/NIAIP.2016.23.3.043
- Publisher : NIA
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy
1한국외국어대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This research analyzes the international standardization process by observing the international communication sources in order to understand the reason of its current poor use. Using the ‘organizing theory’frame, we observe the initial discourse on the need of internationalized domain names in ICANN and the process of negotiation for technical choice of layers. Lastly, we take Korean domain names as a case study in order to understand the conflict and the cooperation of different stakeholders.
We summarize the factors of failure of IDN as follows. First, the need of IDN in the beginning was raised around non-English speaking countries, in Asia and Middle East, with the discourse on ‘digital divide solution and cultural value’ICANN rather pursues the ‘technical stability of Internet Infrastructure’, which made its standardization take as long as 10 years. As a result, a variety of standards and services are proposed in the marketplace, which engendered inefficient competition and domain name-related disputes such as cybersquatting, technical instability and confusion of users. In addition, the government agencies fail to present the appropriate policies adjusting multiple interests of different stakeholders.
Statistics
-
253 Viewed
-
111 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[other]
경향신문
/ 1999
/ 홈페이지 주소대신 명칭 입력해 접속, 넷피아 초보 네티즌에 인기
[other]
경향신문
/ 2003
/ 오늘부터 한글.kr 일반인 등록, 영어는 가라! 도메인 주권 찾았다
[other]
경향신문
/ 2005
/ 인터넷 통제권한 미 독점, 한번 더, WSIS 합의 정책 논의 국제포럼도 창설
[other]
국민일보
/ 2001
/ 아시아키워드연합체, 넷피아, MS 대항 결성
[journal]
권혜미
/ 2014
/ ‘한국’도메인 활용 현황 및 활성화 방안
/ Internet & Security Focus
/ 한국인터넷진흥원
17
: 59~73
[journal]
김영복
/ 2005
/
Application of Korean Alphabet Domain-Names for Convenient Information Access in a Ubiquitous Information Network
/ 정보처리학회논문지C
/ 한국정보처리학회
12(7)
: 1067~1074
[other]
동아일보
/ 2006
/ 인터넷주소, 미 셋방살이 싫다
[other]
매일경제
/ 2000
/ 비영어권 도메인 허용시비
[other]
매일경제
/ 2000
/ 아시아 국가 언어 도메인네임에 대한 찬반논쟁 가열
[other]
매일경제
/ 2000
/ 한중일, 도메인 자국어표기 표준안 제정추진
[other]
매일경제
/ 2006
/ 한글주소 특허 공동소유자끼리 맞소송 사태
[other]
머니투데이
/ 2003
/ 한글키워드 특허권논쟁 수면위로
[other]
머니투데이
/ 2007
/ 한글도메인, 온라인 홍보용으로 인기
[other]
문화일보
/ 2000
/ 한글표기명.com 시대 열린다
[other]
문화일보
/ 2013
/ 포털에 밀린 한글인터넷주소 좌초
[report]
서울대 언론정보연구소
/ 2000
/ 인터넷의 Multilingualization과 국제협력에 관한 연구
/ 한국인터넷정보센터
[other]
세계일보
/ 1999
/ 한글도메인 인기 폭발
[other]
세계일보
/ 2005
/ 인터넷 관할권, 미 독점적 지배에 EU∙개도국들 반발
[other]
IT Daily
/ 2016
/ 베리사인, 한국어 버전 최상위도메인 '.닷컴'∙'.닷넷' 출시
[other]
오마이뉴스
/ 2004
/ 외면당하는 한글도메인, 시장이 죽어간다
[journal]
유재미
/ 2015
/
A Review on E-Governance Research Trend and Analysis - An Empirical Analysis of Academic Papers in Korea -
/ 정보화정책
/ 한국정보화진흥원
22(4)
: 03~21
[journal]
윤건
/ 2013
/
Reorganizing ICT Governance: A Perspective on Regulation and Promotion
/ 정보화정책
/ 한국정보화진흥원
20(2)
: 20~38
[other]
이데일리
/ 2006
/ 인터넷 도메인명 영어 독점 곧 끝날 듯
[journal]
이정현
/ 2012
/
Problems with Chinese Ideographs Search in Unicode and Solutions to Them
/ 정보화정책
/ 한국정보화진흥원
19(3)
: 50~63
[journal]
이진랑
/ 2011
/
유럽 표준화 과정에서의 새로운 이해당사자의 출현: 초국주의와 일국일대표제 사이의 정책적 딜레마
/ 사회과학연구
/ 사회과학연구소
19(2)
: 204~233
[book]
Weick, K. E
/ 1990
/ 조직화 이론
/ 율곡
[journal]
이항우
/ 2009
/
지구화, 인터넷 거버넌스, 그리고 ICANN
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(82)
: 128~160
[journal]
이항우
/ 2010
/
Neoliberal Global Internet Governance and Its Legitimacy : A Case Study of ICANN(1998-2009)
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(87)
: 172~203
[other]
Etnews
/ 2009
/ ‘한글.kr’도메인, 정부마저 외면
[thesis]
정경희
/ 2003
/ 넷피아의 한글인터넷주소 비즈니스 성공 사례 연구: 자국어(한글) 인터넷주소 발전방향 중심으로
/ 석사
/ 동국대학교 경영대학원
[journal]
정찬모
/ 2012
/
An Overview of the Developments of ICANN Internet Governance and Some Recommendations for Korea
/ 정보화정책
/ 한국정보화진흥원
19(3)
: 36~49
[other]
파이낸셜뉴스
/ 2003
/ 한글.com 본격화로 외화 유출
[other]
한겨레
/ 2000
/ 한글.음성.안티…도메인 종류 폭발업무 산더미
[other]
한겨레
/ 2000
/ 한글도메인 피습사건
[other]
한국경제
/ 2001
/ 넷피아닷컴, 키워드 서비스 공식발표
[other]
한국경제
/ 2003
/ 한글키워드서비스, 시장쟁탈전 재점화
[report]
한국인터넷정보센터
/ 2001
/ 한글 도메인 운용상의 안정성 및 상호운용성에 대한 연구
/ 한국인터넷정보센터
[report]
한국인터넷정보센터
/ 2015
/ 국가도메인운영보고서 2015 5월
/ 한국인터넷정보센터
[report]
한국인터넷진흥원
/ 2009
/ 2007년 도메인 관련 국제동향 보고서
/ 한국인터넷진흥원
[report]
한국인터넷진흥원
/ 2015
/ 다국어도메인 이용환경개선. 8월 18일자 동향 분석 보고서
/ 한국인터넷진흥원
[journal]
황철증
/ 1999
/ 인터넷 가브넌스의 이해-IANA와 ICANN의 역사적 분석을 통하여
/ 정보통신정책 ISSUE
11(3)
: 1~79
[confproc]
Antonova, S.
/ 2007
/ Power and Multistakeholderism: The ICANN Experiment
/ Paper presented at Global Internet Governance Academic Network Second Annual Symposium
[journal]
Bernstorff, J.
/ 2003
/ Democratic Global Internet Regulation?: Governance Networks, International Law and the Shadow of Hegemony
/ European Law Journal
9(4)
: 511~526
[confproc]
Callahan, E.
/ 2007
/ Multilingual websites: Language choice, audience, and international identity
/ Paper presented at Internet Research 8.0
[book]
Danet, B.
/ 2007
/ The multilingual internet : language, culture, and communication online
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Delmas, R.
/ 2004
/ L’Internet, governance d’un monde incertain
/ Revue française d’administration publique
110
: 217~224
[other]
Etnews
/ 2009
/ ‘한글.kr’도메인, 정부마저 외면
[other]
EURid
/ 2011
/ Internationalized Domain Names: State of play
/ EURid
[report]
EURid
/ 2012
/ World report on Internationalized Domain Names deployment 2012
/ EURid
[report]
EURid
/ 2013
/ World report on Internationalized Domain Names deployment 2013
/ EURid
[report]
EURid
/ 2014
/ World report on Internationalized Domain Names deployment 2014
/ EURid
[report]
EURid
/ 2015
/ World report on Internationalized Domain Names deployment 2015
/ EURid
[book]
Goggin, G.
/ 2009
/ Internationalizing Internet studies: beyond anglophone paradigms
/ Taylor & Francis
[report]
ICANN
/ 2001
/ Report of the Internationalized Domain Names
/ Internal Working Group of the ICANN Board of Directors
[other]
Information Today
/ 2005
/ WSIS preview
[other]
International Herald Tribune
/ 2006
/ Breakdown…
[other]
IT Daily
/ 2016
/ 베리사인, 한국어 버전 최상위도메인 ‘.닷컴’∙‘.닷넷’출시
[other]
ITU
/ 2001
/ ITU Briefing Paper: Multilingual Domain Names
/ ITU
[journal]
Kleinwachter, W.
/ 2000
/ ICANN between technical mandate and political challenges
/ Telecommunications Policy
24
: 553~563
[other]
Korea Herald
/ 2000
/ Korea, Japan, China to push for native-language domain standards
[thesis]
Lee, J.-R.
/ 2009
/ Processus communicationnel de la normalisation en matiere de TIC en Coree du Sud et en France - pour une construction sociale de la democratie technique
/ Doctor
/ University of Paris X
[confproc]
Leib, V.
/ 2000
/ Internet Governance and Europe's role in the formation of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers(ICANN)
/ Regulating the Internet: EU and US Perspectives, conference paper
/ University of Washington
[journal]
Lenard, T. M.
/ 2011
/ Improving ICANN's governance and accountability: A policy proposal
/ Information Economics and Policy
23
: 189~199
[journal]
Lips, M.
/ 2005
/ Who Regulates and Manages the Internet Infrastructure? Democratic and Legal Risks in Shadow Global Governance
/ Information Polity
10
: 117~128
[web]
Matsuura, J. H.
/ 2000
/ Internet Governance: To Find the Internet’s Once and Future King
/ http://www.isoc.org/inet2000/cdproceedings/8g/8g_3.htm
[book]
Mattelart, A.
/ 1991
/ La Communicationmonde: Histoire des idees et des strategies
/ La Decouverte
[journal]
Mestdagh, C.
/ 2007
/ Rethinking Accountability in Cyberspace: A New Perspective on ICANN
/ International Review of Law Computer and Technology
21(1)
: 27~38
[other]
MINC
/ 2001
/ Concept paper of MINC
/ MINC
[journal]
Mueller, M.
/ 1998
/ The Battle Over Internet Domain Names: Global or National TLDs?
/ Telecommunication Policy
22(2)
: 89~107
[journal]
Milton Mueller
/ 2009
/
ICANN Inc.: Accountability and Participation in the Governance of Critical Internet Resources
/ The Korean Journal of Policy Studies
/ 서울대학교행정대학원
24(2)
: 91~116
[journal]
Mueller, M.
/ 2004
/ The Post-.COM Internet: Toward Regular and Objective Procedures for Internet Governance
/ Telecommunication Policy
28
: 487~502
[journal]
Mueller, M.
/ 2007
/ The Internet and Global Governance: Principles and Norms for a New Regime
/ Global Governance
13
: 237~254
[journal]
우지숙
/ 2005
/
Participation in International Governance Regime by the “Rest of the World””An Analysis of ICANN
/ 사이버커뮤니케이션학보
/ 사이버커뮤니케이션학회
15(1)
: 57~92
[book]
Napoli, Philip, M.
/ 2013
/ Pluralisme de l’Information et media diversity; un e tat des lieux international
/ de boeck
: 39~58
[report]
NETmundial
/ 2014
/ NETmundial draft outcome document public consultation: final report on comments
[other]
NetWork World
/ 2000
/ Multilingual domain names could strain corporate nets
[other]
Network World
/ 2002
/ RealNames fall may doom keywords
[journal]
Pimienta, D.
/ 2001
/ Quel espace dans l'Internet en dehors de la langue anglaise et de la culture “made in USA”?
/ Les Cahiers du numerique
2
: 205~224
[other]
PR Newswire
/ 2000
/ New Technology poised to make Internet a truly international medium
[book]
Schiller, H. I.
/ 1976
/ Communication and Cultural Domination
/ International Arts and Sciences Press
[journal]
Siapera, E.
/ 2006
/ Multiculturalism online: the Internet and the dilemmas of multicultural politics
/ European Journal of Cultural Studies
9(1)
: 5~24
[other]
The Guardian
/ 2006
/ Divided by a common language
[other]
The Register
/ 2005
/ Arab warning over ongoing US government control
[other]
The Wall Street Journal
/ 2006
/ Threat to Internet’s Clout, Some are Starting Alternatives
[other]
Warren’s Washington Internet Daily
/ 2006
/ Alternate Root Threaten ICANN Health
[other]
Warren’s Washington Internet Daily
/ 2006
/ Internet Multilingualism a Threat to Interoperability?
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.