Unplanned and Unauthorized Prosperity under the Planned Economy: A County-Level Revisit of Chinese Peasants’ Participation in Illegal Markets during the Cultural Revolution

Sanjiao Tang

Unplanned and Unauthorized Prosperity under the Planned Economy: A County-Level Revisit of Chinese Peasants’ Participation in Illegal Markets during the Cultural Revolution

Asia Review
Abbr : SNUACAR
2023, 13(1), pp.253~288
Publisher : 아시아연구소
Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
Received : December 15, 2022
Accepted : April 3, 2023
Published : April 30, 2023

Sanjiao Tang ¹

¹독립연구자

Accredited

ABSTRACT

In today’s China, legacies of the centrally planned economy under Mao Zedong’s rule are being rejuvenated, which coincides with the trend of reevaluating Mao-era history more positively. For example, Supply and Marketing Cooperatives, the forces of the planned economy that dominated Chinese peasants’ marketing and purchase of products, are regaining influence in rural China. Opposite to the Supply and Marketing Cooperatives were free businesses, which faced serious restrictions and crackdowns throughout the planned economy era. Although China deviated from the model of the planned economy decades ago, a lack of sufficient bottom-up evidence has prevented researchers from presenting a clear picture of rural residents’ experiences under the planned economy, such as how they suffered from and responded to the minimization of free rural markets. This deficiency in research foreshadows the revival of the Supply and Marketing Cooperatives in a glamorized form. Based on large numbers of primary and archival sources, this article pays a county-level revisit to Chinese peasants’ continuous attempts to trade their harvest freely, especially through participating in illegal markets, during the Cultural Revolution (1966–1976). Through exploring the unplanned and unauthorized prosperity in rural commerce that went beyond lawful boundaries, the research aims to reassess Chinese peasants’ authentic marketing experiences under the planned economy, so as to provide evidence-based references for reconsidering today’s popular reevaluation of Mao-era legacies molded by the planned economy.

KEYWORDS

planned economy, rural business, black market, Cultural Revolution

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] / 2020 / An account book of a rural family of Fuling District, Chongqing City, found in an old-book market in Chongqing City

[other] / 2019 / A record sheet of peasants’ work points of a Hechuan production team, found in an old-book market in Hechuan District / Chongqing City

[other] Hechuanxian gongshang xingzheng guanliju 合川县工商行政管理局 [Bureau of Industry and Commerce Administration of Hechuan County] / 1989 / 合川工商行政管理志 Hechuanxian gongshang xingzheng guanli zhi (Gazetteer of Industry and Commerce Administration of Hechuan) / Internal materials

[other] Hechuanxian gongxiao hezuo lianshe 合川县供销合作联社 [The Supply and Marketing Cooperatives of Hechuan County] / 1989 / 合川县供销合作志 (1937-1985) Hechuanxian gongxiao hezuo zhi (1937-1985) (Gazetteer of the Supply and Marketing Cooperatives of Hechua: 1937-1985) / Internal materials

[other] / 2020 / Informal discussion with a resident who grew up in rural Hechuan during the Cultural Revolution, male

[other] / 2021 / Work notes of a Chongqing cadre in the 1970s, found in an old-book market in Chongqing City

[book] Yang Chengshu杨成术 / 2013 / 合川文史资料第二十一辑 Hechuan wenshi ziliao diershiyiji (The Cultural and Historical Materials of Hechuan, Volume 21) / 政协重庆市合川区委员会文史资料委员会 Zhengxie Chongqingshi Hechuanqu weiyuanhui wenshi ziliao weiyuanhui [Committee of Culture and History of Hechuan District, Chongqing City, of the CPPCC]

[other] Zhongguo nongye yinhang Hechuanxian zhihang 中国农业银行合川县支行[Hechuan Branch of the Agricultural Bank of China] / 1990 / 合川农村金融志1937-1988 Hechuan nongcun jinrong zhi 1937-1988 (Gazetteer of Rural Finance of Hechuan, 1937-1988) / Internal materials

[book] Zhou Yun周云 / 2008 / 合川文史资料第二十二辑 Hechuan wenshi ziliao diershiyiji (The Cultural and Historical Materials of Hechuan, Volume 22) / Internal materials

[book] Brown, Jeremy / 2015 / Maoism at the Grassroots : Everyday Life in China’s Era of High Socialism / Harvard University Press

[journal] Chan, Anita / 1982 / Grey and Black : The Hidden Economy of. Rural China / Pacific Affairs 55(3) : 452~471

[book] Chan, Anita / 1992 / Chen Village under Mao and Deng : expanded and updated edition / University of California Press

[book] Cheng Liansheng 程连升 / 筚路蓝缕：计划经济在中国 Bilulanlü: jihua jingji zai Zhongguo (Enduring Great Hardships in Pioneer Work: The Planned Economy in China) / Zhonggong dangshi chubanshe

[journal] Dikötter, Frank / 2016 / The Silent Revolution : Decollectivization from Below during the Cultural Revolution / The China Quarterly 227 : 796~811

[book] Friedman, Edward / 1991 / Chinese Village, Socialist State / Yale University Press

[book] Friedman, Edward / 2005 / Revolution, Resistance, and Reform in Village China / Yale University Press

[book] Gao Wangling 高王凌 / 2006 / 人民公社时期中国农民“反行为”调查 Renmin gongshe shiqi zhongguo nongmin “fanxingwei” diaocha (An Investigation of Chinese Peasants’ “Resisting Behaviors” during the People’s Commune Period) / Zhonggong dangshi chubanshe

[book] Gao Wangling 高王凌 / 2013 / 中国农民反行为研究1950–1980 Zhongguo nongmin fanxingwei yanjiu 1950–1980 (A Study of Chinese Peasants’ “Resisting Behaviors” between 1950 and 1980) / The Chinese University of Hong Kong Press

[book] Hechuan xianzhi bianzhuan weiyuanhui 合川县志编撰委员会 [Editorial Committee of Gazetteer of Hechuan County] / 1996 / 合川县志 Hechuan xianzhi (Gazetteer of Hechuan County) / Sichuan Renmin Chubanshe

[other] Hou Xuejing 侯雪静 / 2021 / 供销总社：每年打造1000个乡镇为农服务综合体 Gongxiao zongshe: meinian dazao 1000 ge xiangzhen weinong fuwu zongheti (The Headquarters of the Supply and Marketing Cooperatives: build one thousand township-level servicing complexes) / 新华社新媒体 (The New Media of the Xinhua News Agency)

[book] Huang, Philip C / 1990 / The Peasant Family and Rural Development in the Yangzi Delta, 1350-1988 / Stanford University Press

[thesis] Ma Yonghui 马永辉 / 2005 / 1949–1966苏北农村集市贸易变迁 1949–1966 Subei nongcun jishi maoyi bianqian (The Transformations of Rural Market in Northern Jiangsu between 1949 and 1966) / Ph.D. / The Party School of the Central Committee of the CCP

[other] Ren Jiao 任娇 / 2022 / 年销售6.26万亿元没想到你是这样的供销社 Nian xiaoshou 6.26 wanyi yuan meixiangdao nishi zheyangde gongxiaoshe (With annual sales amounting to RMB 6.26 trillion, did not recognize that you are the Supply and Marketing Cooperatives in such a style) / 新京报 (The Beijing News)

[journal] Skinner, G. W / 1964 / Marketing and Social Structure in Rural China : Part I / The Journal of Asian Studies 24(1) : 3~43

[journal] Skinner, G. W / 1965 / Marketing and Social Structure in Rural China : Part II / The Journal of Asian Studies 24(2) : 195~228

[book] Skinner, G. W / 1977 / The City in Late Imperial China / Stanford University Press : 288~298

[journal] Wang, Chunying / 2022 / Gray Markets in the Great Leap : Prosecuting"Profiteering"in Liangshan County, Shandong, 1958–1960 / Modern China 48(5) : 948~981

[book] Wang Di 王笛 / 1993 / 跨出封闭的世界―长江上游区域社会研究1644–1911 Kuachu fengbi de shijie—Changjiang shangyou quyu shehui yanjiu 1644-1911(Breaking up a Closed World: The Social Transformation of the Upper Yangtze Region) / Zhonghua Shuju

[book] Wang Gang 王纲 / 1991 / 清代四川史 Qingdai Sichuan shi(History of Sichuan during the Qing Dynasty) / Chengdu Keji Daxue Chubanshe

[book] Zhou, Kate Xiao / 1996 / How the Farmers Changed China : Power of the People / Westview Press

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Asia Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.86