China’s Gray Zone Strategy: The Case of South China Sea Conflict (중국의 회색지대 전략: 남중국해 분쟁 사례를 중심으로)

Yue Ma (마월); Bonyun Gu (구본윤)

China’s Gray Zone Strategy: The Case of South China Sea Conflict

Facebook
X(Twitter)

Asia Review
Abbr : SNUACAR
2023, 13(2), pp.31~58
Publisher : 아시아연구소
Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
Received : June 15, 2023
Accepted : July 31, 2023
Published : August 31, 2023

Yue Ma ¹, Bonyun Gu ¹

¹연세대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This paper seeks to examine the gray zone strategy used by China in the South China Sea Conflict and to analyze the mechanisms of the gray zone strategy. Using the existing data set on ‘South China Sea’ from 1970 to 2020, we analyze the theoretical characteristics and strategic impact of the gray zone strategy by China. We argue that the internal variable such as ‘reputation’, and the external variables such as ‘status quo dilemma’ and the ‘ambiguity of international law’ constitute a compromised gray zone strategy. These findings clarify the mechanism by which the gray zone strategy is adopted as a tool of China, providing an avenue for new research on the gray zone strategy.

KEYWORDS

South China Sea, China, Gray zone strategy, Reputation, Status quo dilemma, International law

Statistics

567 Viewed
373 Downloaded

Tools

Print this page
Download PDF

Issue List

Vol.15 No.1
Vol.14 No.3
Vol.14 No.2

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2024 are currently being built.

[journal] 구민교 / 2016 / The New Rivalry between the United States and China: Competing Strategies for the Points, Lines, and Planes at Sea / 국제.지역연구 / 국제학연구소 25(3) : 37~65

[journal] 구자선 / 2015 / 시진핑 체제 중국외교 기조의 지속과 변화 / 인차이나브리프 (302) : 1~19

[book] 김상걸 / 2019 / 법의 정치화 및 무기화 : 하이브리드 전쟁 수단으로서의 법률전 / 국가안보전략연구원

[journal] 김상걸 / 2021 / The Context and Concept of Lawfare as a Means of Hybrid Warfare / 아주법학 / 법학연구소 15(1) : 105~135

[journal] 김상걸 / 2021 / Examining Actual Implementations of Lawfare — The United States, China, Russia and the Middle East — / 미국헌법연구 / 미국헌법학회 32(1) : 167~210

[journal] 김석수 / 2010 / The international relation on South China Sea：at the core of Paracel and Spratly Islands’ disputes / 국가안보와 전략 / 국가안보전략연구원 10(4) : 257~286

[journal] 김소연 / 2022 / China’s Maritime Police Law and the amended Maritime Traffic Safety Law – Analysis on their Conformity to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea / 아주법학 / 법학연구소 15(4) : 398~429

[journal] 김진호 / 2020 / China’s Marine Gray Zone Strategy and Korea’s Response / 한국동북아논총 / 한국동북아학회 25(2) : 81~100

[journal] 김태성 / 2018 / Strategic Response of Korea by China’s Military Power Strengthening : Korea by Focusing on Security Policy Direction and Military Response Strategy / 한국동북아논총 / 한국동북아학회 23(3) : 89~110

[journal] 김택연 / 2016 / U.S.-China Relations and South China Sea Conflict / 아태연구 / 국제지역연구원 23(2) : 41~76

[thesis] 남동우 / 2022 / 중국의 회색지대 전략과 한국의 대응방안 연구 / 박사 / 한국해양대학교

[journal] 류병운 / 2020 / The International Law against Use of Force and New Security Threats - Focusing on Cyber War and Hybrid Warfare - / 외법논집 / 법학연구소 44(3) : 157~187

[journal] 민귀식 / 2021 / Vietnam and the Philippines' response to the U.S.-China gray-zone strategy competition in the South China Sea. / 중국지식네트워크 / 중국인문사회연구소 18(18) : 39~106

[journal] 박동준 / 2021 / The Role of Reputation for Resolve in Crisis Decision-Making: On the Cases of the First and Second Taiwan Strait Crises of the 1950s / 국제정치연구 / 동아시아국제정치학회 24(3) : 63~87

[journal] 반길주 / 2020 / The Gray Zone Strategy of Northeast Asian States and South Korea’s Bespoke Counter-Measures / 한국군사 / (재)한국군사문제연구원 7 : 35~69

[journal] 신종호 / 2016 / Change in China’s Foreign Strategy in the Xi Jinping Era and Its Impact on China’s Policy on Korean Peninsula / 통일정책연구 / 통일연구원 25(2) : 133~157

[journal] 양욱 / 2020 / Gray Zone Conflict Strategy: The concept of gray zone conflict and its military implications / 전략연구 / (사) 한국전략문제연구소 27(3) : 249~280

[other] 오종석 / 2009 / 중 ·미, 남중국해 대치국면 확산 조짐 / 국민일보

[journal] 류동원 / 2015 / China’s South China Sea strategy: Changes and Backgrounds / 중소연구 / 아태지역연구센터 39(3) : 185~219

[journal] 유철종 / 2005 / A Study on Territorial Dispute over the Spratly Islands in the south China Sea / 정치·정보연구 / 한국정치정보학회 8(2) : 1~36

[journal] 이대우 / 2016 / 남중국해 영유권 분쟁과 미중관계 / KINU 통일＋ 2(3) : 4~19

[journal] 이동선 / 2017 / Long Asymmetric Wars in a Bipolar System : A Theoretical Analysis of the Vietnam War / 아세아연구 / 아세아문제연구원 60(2) : 422~455

[journal] 이상엽 / 2017 / 북핵·미사일 시대의 억제전략 : 도전과 나아갈 방향 / STRATEGY 21 20(1) : 232~260

[journal] 이상현 / 2020 / Japan’s Response to China’s Maritime Gray Zone Strategy / 일본연구논총 / 현대일본학회 (52) : 91~122

[journal] 이상회 / 2021 / A Study on the International Legal Status and Effective Countermeasures toward Chinese Maritime Militia / 한국해양경찰학회보 / 한국해양경찰학회 11(2) : 325~355

[book] 이서항 / 2020 / 동아시아 해양분쟁과 중국의 회색지대 전략 / 인간사랑 : 31~50

[other] 이은택 / 2022 / 美 “中, 남중국해 인공섬 최소 3곳 군사화 완료” / 동아일보

[journal] 이은택 / 2019 / US-China Rivalry in the South China Sea Disputes: Offensive Realist Approach / 국제관계연구 / 일민국제관계연구원 24(1) : 81~132

[journal] 이지용 / 2014 / Evolving China’s National Identity and Changing Maritime Security Environment in East Asia / 국제관계연구 / 일민국제관계연구원 19(1) : 77~114

[journal] 정구연 / 2018 / Sino-US Power Transiton and Evolving US Maritme Strategy Analyzing Grey-Zone Conflict in the Asia-Pacifc / 국가전략 / 세종연구소 24(3) : 87~112

[journal] 정민정 / 2022 / Relationship Between the South China Sea Arbitration and U.S. Freedom of Navigation Operations / 법학연구 / 법학연구소 30(1) : 121~146

[journal] 조용수 / 2020 / 중국의 회색지대전략 메커니즘 분석을 통한 남중국해 및 동중국해 분쟁양상 비교: 시계열 데이터에 근거한 경험적 연구를 중심으로 / 해양안보 1(1) : 273~310

[web] 최현호 / 2023 / 中 관측기구, 세계 곳곳에 퍼져있다… ‘회색지대 전략’ 뭐길래 / https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25141534

[book] 표나리 / 2023 / 중국의 회색지대 전략과 3전의 전개: 한국에 대한 함의 / 국립외교원 외교안보연구소

[web] 한국국방연구원 / 2022 / 지역별 분쟁 분석자료 / https://www.kida.re.kr/frt/board/frtNormalBoardDetail.do?sidx=2166&idx=91%20&depth=3&searchCondition=&searchKeyword=&pageIndex=1&lang=kr

[journal] 황원준 / 2020 / The DPRK's Gray Zone Strategy: A Case of Short Range Missile Launch / 국방연구 / 국가안전보장문제연구소 63(4) : 1~30

[other] 人民日报 / 2012 / 习近平: 紧紧围绕坚持和发展中国特色社会主义学习宣传贯彻党的十八大精神

[other] 新华网 / 2023 / 以习近平同志为核心的党中央2022年治国理政述评

[other] 张加军 / 2010 / 专家: 核心利益长期被侵涉台等问题局部反攻 / 环球网

[web] 中國南海网 / 2022 / 大事记 / http://www.thesouthchinasea.org.cn/events.html

[other] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府 / 2012 / 外交部发言人秦刚就美国务院发表所谓南海问题声明阐明中方严正立场

[other] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府 / 2013 / 王毅: 警惕个别国家为一己私利在南海兴风作浪

[other] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府 / 2013 / 王毅谈南海问题时指出中国愿与东盟共同努力排除干扰, 维护南海和平稳定

[other] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府 / 2014 / 中国驻菲律宾大使馆就菲律宾向南海问题国际仲裁庭提交书面陈述举行媒体吹风会

[other] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府 / 2014 / 外交部发言人洪磊就美方涉南海言论答记者问

[journal] Bhatia, Kapil / 2018 / Coercive Gradualism through Gray Zone Statecraft in the South China Seas: China’s Strategy and Potential U.S. Options / Joint Force Quarterly 91(4) : 24~33

[book] Echevarria, Antulio J. II / 2016 / Operating in the Gray Zone: An Alternative Paradigm for U.S. Military Strategy / Strategic Studies Institute

[web] Erickson, Andrew S. / Exposed: Pentagon Report Spotlights China’s Maritime Militia / https://nationalinterest.org/feature/exposed-pentagon-reportspotlights-china%E2%80%99s-maritime-militia-29282

[other] Erickson, Andrew S. / 2016 / China’s Maritime Militia : What It Is and How ti Deal with It / Foreign Affairs

[book] Green, Michael J. / 2017 / Countering Coercion in Maritime Asia: The Theory and Practice of Gray Zone Deterrence / CSIS(Center for Strategic &International Studies)

[book] Harold, Scott W. / 2017 / The US-Japan Alliance and Deterring Gray Zone Coercion in the Maritime, Cyber, and Space Domain / RAND Corporation

[book] Hoffman, Frank G / 2016 / Index of U.S. Military Strength / The Heritage Foundation

[journal] Ikenberry, G. John / 2014 / The Illusion of Geopolitics : The Enduring Power of the Liberal Order / Foreign Affairs 93(3) : 80~90

[journal] Johnston, Alastair Iain / 2003 / Is China a Status Quo Power / International Security 27(4) : 5~65

[journal] Kang, David C / 2003 / Getting Asia Wrong : The Need for New Analytical Frameworks / International Security 27(4) : 57~85

[book] Mazarr, Michael J / 2015 / Mastering the Gray Zone: Understanding a Changing Era of Conflict / United States Army War College Press

[journal] Mead, Walter Russell / 2014 / The Return of Geopolitics : The Revenge of the Revisionist Powers / Foreign Affairs 93(3) : 69~79

[book] Mearsheimer, John J / 2014 / The Tragedy of Great Power Politics / W. W. Norton & Company

[book] Morris, Lyle J. / 2019 / Gaining Competitive Advantage in the Gray Zone: Response Options for Coercive Aggression Below the Threshold of Major War / RAND Corporation

[journal] Roy, Denny / 1994 / Hegemon on the Horizon? China’s threat to East Asian Security / International Security 19(1) : 149~168

[journal] Segal, Gerald / 1996 / East Asia and the ‘Constrainment’ of China / International Security 20(4) : 159~187

[book] Shimshoni, Jonathan / 1988 / Israel and Conventional Deterrence / Cornell University

[journal] Takahashi, Sugio / 2018 / Development of Gray-zone Deterrence : Concept Building and Lessons from Japan’s Experience / The Pacific Review 31(6) : 787~810

[report] U. S. Department of Defense / 2010 / Quadrennial Defense Review Report / U.S. Department of Defense

[journal] Walter, Barbara F / 2006 / Building Reputation : Why Governments Fight Some Separatists but not Others / American Journal of Political Science 50(2) : 313~330

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Asia Review 2024 KCI Impact Factor : 0.96