Journal of Special Education: Theory and Practice 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.96
-
pISSN : 1598-060X / eISSN : 2734-0090
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jsped
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Meta-analysis of single subject researches for students with difficulty in writing: focusing on students with mild intellectual disabilities, learning disabilities, and low achievement
- Journal of Special Education: Theory and Practice
- Abbr : JSPED
- 2018, 19(2), pp.123-148
- DOI : 10.19049/JSPED.2018.19.2.06
- Publisher : Research Institute of the Korea Special Education
- Research Area : Social Science > Education
- Received : May 14, 2018
- Accepted : June 12, 2018
- Published : June 30, 2018
Ko Seo Yeon 1, Baek Young-Sun 1, Hanah Kil 1, Meiling Jin 1, Sakura Yusuke 1, Son Seung Hyun 1
1고려대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of writing interventions on "students with difficulty in writing" defining students with mild intellectual disabilities, learning disabilities, and low achievement. A meta-analysis was conducted by collecting single-subject research about writing intervention for those students. In addition, through the meta-ANOVA, the control variables were divided into the subject-related variables(type, gender, grade, IQ) and the intervention -related variables(type, session, time, and writing target area). A total of 34 articles were analyzed from 2001 to 2017, and a total of 159 effect sizes(Tau-U) were derived. As a result of the meta-analysis, the effectiveness of the writing intervention studies were proved, and the moderating effect was shown in the intervention session and intervention time. Finally, the limitations and implications of this study were discussed.
Statistics
-
474 Viewed
-
262 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
강종구
/ 2012
/
Perspectives: Social Construction Approach to Intellectual Disabilities
/ 지적장애연구
/ 한국지적장애교육학회
14(2)
: 1~23
[other]
국립특수교육원
/ 1996
/ KISE 학습장애선별척도
/ 국립특수교육원
[journal]
권현욱
/ 2010
/
Effect of Phonemic Awareness Training on the Dictation and Writing Fluency of Academic Underachievers in the Elementary School
/ 특수교육저널:이론과 실천
/ 한국특수교육문제연구소
11(1)
: 337~358
[journal]
김경진
/ 2015
/
The Impacts of Interest Based Writing Activities on Word Reading and Writing of Students with Intellectual Disabilities Placed at a Special School
/ 발달장애연구
/ 한국발달장애학회
19(2)
: 1~22
[journal]
김길순
/ 2008
/
The Effects of Phonological Awareness Training on Spelling Skill in Children with Learning Disabilities
/ 특수교육재활과학연구
/ 특수교육재활과학연구소
47(4)
: 1~25
[book]
김동일
/ 2003
/ 학습장애아동의 이해와 교육
/ 학지사
[journal]
김동일
/ 2013
/
Meta-analysis of Writing Learning Disability for Single-subject Intervention Researches in Korea
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
10(2)
: 73~92
[journal]
김민정
/ 2013
/
The Effects of Writing Instruction with Self-Regulated Strategy Development on the Narrative Composition of Students with Learning Disabilities
/ Communication Sciences and Disorders
/ 한국언어청각임상학회
18(4)
: 402~416
[journal]
김애화
/ 2013
/
The Effect of Phonological-Based Spelling Instruction on Spelling of Students with Writing Disabilities
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
10(2)
: 51~72
[journal]
김애화
/ 2015
/
The Effects of Spelling Instruction Based on Korean Language Characteristics on Spelling Achievement of Words with Final Double in Students with Writing Disabilities
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
12(3)
: 43~67
[journal]
김영한
/ 2002
/ 의미중심적 쓰기지도가 초등학교 저학년 쓰기장애아의 의미표현적 쓰기와 관습적 쓰기에 미치는 영향
/ 지적장애연구
4
: 215~232
[journal]
김유정
/ 2016
/
Peer Tutoring by a Senior Student with Imitation Strategy on the Writing Underachiever’s and Peer Instructor’s Writing Abilities
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
13(3)
: 91~115
[book]
김윤옥
/ 2001
/ 학습장애아교육 최중옥편, 특수아동의 이해와 교육
/ 교육과학사
[journal]
김윤옥
/ 2004
/
Discrepancy Between Scholarly Definitions of Learning Disabilities and Elementary Special Educators’ Diagnostic Practices on LD
/ 특수교육학연구
/ 한국특수교육학회
39(2)
: 85~103
[journal]
김윤옥
/ 2003
/
Effects towards the Writing Abilities and Self-Efficacy of Elementary Students with LD by a Sentence Writing Strategy
/ 특수교육학연구
/ 한국특수교육학회
38(3)
: 241~258
[journal]
김윤희
/ 2007
/
Effects of Using Dialogue Journal Writing on Reflective Writing and Problem Behaviors of Children with Mental Retardation.
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
9(1)
: 131~155
[journal]
김자경
/ 2011
/
Effects of Process-based Writing Instruction with Rubric Assessment on the Writing Abilities and Writing Efficacy of Children with Writing Disabilities
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
13(4)
: 513~535
[journal]
김지은
/ 2014
/
The Effects of Writing Instruction with Self-Regulated Strategy Development on Persuasive Writing of Student with Learning Disability
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
11(1)
: 173~204
[journal]
김진화
/ 2015
/
The Analysis of Research Trends on Writing Targeting at the Children with Disabilities
/ 한국청각언어장애교육연구
/ 한국청각언어장애교육학회
6(2)
: 81~102
[book]
박현숙
/ 2007
/ 학습장애 토대, 특성, 효과적 교수
/ 시그마프레스
[journal]
백은정
/ 2012
/
Effects of Self-monitoring on Spelling Skills of Students with Learning Disabilities on Writing
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
9(1)
: 67~88
[journal]
변찬석
/ 2013
/
Elementary Teacher's Perception toward Students with Learning Disability or Underachiever
/ 시각장애연구
/ 한국시각장애교육&재활학회
29(4)
: 177~200
[journal]
손승현
/ 2017
/
International Context of Special Needs Education
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
14(3)
: 25~47
[journal]
신미경
/ 2016
/
Reading Interventions for Improving Phonological Awareness and Word Recognition of Students With Disabilities: A Meta-Analysis of Single-Subject Research Designs
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
18(2)
: 45~75
[journal]
신재현
/ 2017
/
Self-Regulated Strategy Development(SRSD) Interventions for Students at Risk or with Disabilities in Writing: A Literature Review
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
14(1)
: 75~98
[journal]
신말옥
/ 2015
/
The Effect of E-NIE Program on the Reading Fluency and Writing of a Student with Intellectual Disabilities
/ 발달장애연구
/ 한국발달장애학회
19(3)
: 1~24
[journal]
양민화
/ 2016
/
Effects of phonics - based spelling instruction on LD students' writing skills
/ 작문연구
/ 한국작문학회
(29)
: 241~274
[journal]
양정윤
/ 2014
/
The Effects of SNS-based Writing Activities on Writing Underachiever's Writing Abilities and Writing Attitudes
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
11(3)
: 65~92
[report]
엄재용
/ 2004
/ ICT활용 단어학습프로그램이 정신지체아동의 낱말 읽기 및 쓰기에 미치는 효과
: 3~66
[journal]
윤송이
/ 2008
/
Effects of Self-Regulated Strategy Development Instruction on Writing Ability for Children with Writing Disabilities
/ 특수교육저널:이론과 실천
/ 한국특수교육문제연구소
9(3)
: 129~150
[journal]
윤희봉
/ 2005
/
The Effects of Scribble Activity on the Figure-Ground Discrimination and Copy Writing Error for Children with Mental Retardation
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
7(4)
: 67~90
[journal]
이선화
/ 2007
/
The Effects of Self-Regulated Strategy Training on the Writing Competence of Children with Mildly Mental Retardation
/ 통합교육연구
/ 한국통합교육학회
2(2)
: 81~96
[journal]
이애진
/ 2016
/
Exploring the effects of tier 2 Korean phonics intervention for students with spelling difficulties
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
13(3)
: 117~141
[journal]
이영철
/ 2010
/
Changes and Recent Trends in Terms of 'Intellectual Disabilities'
/ 지적장애연구
/ 한국지적장애교육학회
12(3)
: 1~24
[journal]
이예다나
/ 2015
/
Evaluating the Quality Indicator of Reading Intervention Studies for Students with Intellectual Disabilities
/ 지적장애연구
/ 한국지적장애교육학회
17(3)
: 101~129
[journal]
이예다나
/ 2014
/
Analysis on Intervention Studies on Writing Intervention Based on Quality Indicator
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
16(2)
: 477~500
[journal]
이옥인
/ 2017
/
Effects of Online Tool for Self-assessment in Writing and Goal-setting on the Spelling, Word-spacing and MLU of Students with Learning Disabilities
/ 예술인문사회 융합 멀티미디어 논문지
/ 사단법인 인문사회과학기술융합학회
7(1)
: 763~774
[journal]
이혜정
/ 2009
/
The Effect of Nursery Rhyme Activities on Dictation Ability of Underachievers
/ 통합교육연구
/ 한국통합교육학회
4(2)
: 1~21
[journal]
이효선
/ 2011
/
고반응 행동 활용 전략(High-P 전략)을 이용한 교수가 장애 학생의 낱말쓰기 과제수행 및 성취도에 미치는 영향
/ 특수교육
/ 특수교육연구소
10(2)
: 25~53
[journal]
이효신
/ 2002
/
The Effects on Providing Alternative Thinking Strategy with Illustration to Increase Reading and Writing Skills for Children with Learning Disabilities
/ 언어치료연구
/ 한국언어치료학회
11(2)
: 23~40
[journal]
임남순
/ 2006
/ 초등학교 학습장애 아동 및 학습부진 아동에 대한 문장작성전략의 중재효과
/ 학습장애연구
3(2)
: 29~47
[journal]
정광조
/ 2017
/
Effects of Writing Instruction Studies for Students with Learning Disability and Low achievement in Korea: A Meta-Analysis with R
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
14(1)
: 99~122
[journal]
정애라
/ 2015
/
Teachers' Perceptions on the Causes of Learning Problems and Effective Instructional Methods according to Students Types: Comparisons of Students with LD, ID, Under-achieving, and Normal Achieving Students
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
12(2)
: 115~134
[journal]
정은혜
/ 2010
/ 문장작성전략이 학습장애 학생의 이야기 꾸며 쓰기능력에 미치는 효과
/ 학습전략중재연구
1(2)
: 73~93
[journal]
정진자
/ 2001
/ 멀티미디어 문자학습 프로그램이 정신지체아의 단어 읽기와 쓰기에 미치는 효과
/ 언어치료연구
10(2)
: 109~136
[journal]
정혜승
/ 2008
/
An Analytic Review of the Research Methods and Results for The Students with Writing Disabilities in Korea
/ 특수교육학연구
/ 한국특수교육학회
42(4)
: 169~191
[journal]
조성숙
/ 2016
/
A Study on Phonological Processing Abilities and Writing Abilities of Children with Mild Mental Retardation and Normal Children Group
/ 특수교육재활과학연구
/ 특수교육재활과학연구소
55(3)
: 487~504
[journal]
조은호
/ 2010
/ 경도 지적장애집단과 정상아동집단의 이야기 쓰기능력
/ 통합치료연구
2(2)
: 5~24
[journal]
조홍중
/ 2012
/
A Study on the Concepts of ‘Developmental Disabilities’
/ 발달장애연구
/ 한국발달장애학회
16(3)
: 1~21
[journal]
최다희
/ 2013
/
The Effects of Self-Regulated Strategy Development on Persuasive Writing of Students with Learning Disabilities
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
10(2)
: 131~159
[journal]
최덕경
/ 2001
/ MALL의 선택적ᆞ단계적 적용이 학습장애아의 낱말 읽기와 쓰기 능력에 미치는 효과
/ 언어청각장애연구
10(2)
: 137~156
[journal]
최우수
/ 2015
/
Trends Regarding Korean Language Writing Interventions for Students with Intellectual Disabilities
/ 특수교육학연구
/ 한국특수교육학회
50(2)
: 17~40
[journal]
최은영
/ 1998
/ 직접교수와 활동중심중재에 대한 비교연구
/ 재활과학연구
14(1)
: 129~149
[journal]
최정미
/ 2011
/
The effect of Shape Design Tasks Performance Intervention on Writing Skills of Children with Learning Disabilities
/ 특수교육저널:이론과 실천
/ 한국특수교육문제연구소
12(4)
: 27~46
[journal]
최정미
/ 2006
/
The Effects of Dictated Experience Stories Program on Reading and Writing Ability for Children with Learning Disabilities
/ 정서·행동장애연구
/ 한국정서행동장애학회
22(1)
: 153~174
[journal]
최정미
/ 2012
/
A Survey on the Perception of Learning Disabilities in Teachers of General Elementary and Middle School
/ 특수교육재활과학연구
/ 특수교육재활과학연구소
51(3)
: 291~311
[journal]
최한나
/ 2013
/
Instructional Strategies to Enhance the Spelling Ability of Students with Learning Disabilities: A Research Synthesis
/ 학습장애연구
/ 한국학습장애학회
10(1)
: 123~150
[journal]
한경임
/ 2002
/
The Effects of Multimedia Learning Program onReading and Writing of Children with Learning Disabilities
/ 정서·행동장애연구
/ 한국정서행동장애학회
18(2)
: 47~72
[journal]
홍성두
/ 2017
/
Meta-analysis of Single Subject Intervention Researches for Students with Writing Learning Disability in Korea
/ 한국초등교육
/ 초등교육연구원
28(1)
: 307~328
[book]
황성동
/ 2014
/ 알기 쉬운 메타분석의 이해
/ 학지사
[journal]
황지현
/ 2012
/
The Effects of collaborative teamwork intervention for using low-tech assistive technology on the writing legibility and time of middle school students with intellectual disabilities
/ 특수아동교육연구
/ 한국특수아동학회
14(1)
: 339~363
[journal]
Botts, D. C.
/ 2014
/ A comparison of activity-based intervention and embedded direct instruction when teaching emergent literacy skills
/ The Journal of Special Education
48(2)
: 120~134
[journal]
Cole, K. N.
/ 1986
/ Direct language instruction and interactive language instruction with language delayed preschool children : A comparison study. Journal of Speech, Language
/ and Hearing Research
29(2)
: 206~217
[journal]
Cole, K. N.
/ 1989
/ A comparison of the effects of academic and cognitive curricula for young handicapped children one and two years postprogram
/ Topics in Early Childhood Special Education
9(3)
: 110~127
[journal]
Dale, P. S.
/ 1988
/ Comparison of academic and cognitive programs for young handicapped children
/ Exceptional Children
54(5)
: 439~447
[other]
Fuchs, D.
/ 2001
/ Is " Learning Disabilities" Just a Fancy Term for Low Achievement?: A Meta-Analysis of Reading Differences Between Low Achievers with and Without the Label
/ Executive Summary. ERIC Clearinghouse
[thesis]
Giumento, A. S.
/ 1991
/ The effectiveness of two intervention procedures on the acquisition and generalization of object labels by young children who are at risk or who have developmental delays
/ Doctor
/ University of Oregon
[journal]
Gottlieb, J.
/ 1994
/ Special education in urban America : It’s not justifiable for many
/ The Journal of Special Education
27
: 453~465
[other]
Gresham, F.
/ 2001
/ Responsiveness to Intervention: An Alternative Approach to the Identification of Learning Disabilities
/ Executive Summary
[other]
Hallahan, D. P.
/ 2002
/ Learning disabilities: Historical perspectives
/ Unpublished paper presented at the LD Summit
[book]
Hedes, L. V.
/ 1985
/ Statistical methods for meta-analysis
/ Academic Press
[journal]
Hedges, L. V.
/ 1998
/ Fixed-and random-effects models in meta-analysis
/ Psychological Methods
3(4)
: 486~504
[book]
Iyengar, S.
/ 2009
/ Handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis
: 417~433
[other]
Kavale, K. A.
/ 2001
/ Discrepancy Models in the Identification of Learning Disability
/ Executive Summary
[journal]
Losardo, A.
/ 1994
/ Activity-based intervention and direct instruction : A comparison study
/ American Journal on Mental Retardation
98(6)
: 744~765
[journal]
MacMillan, D. L.
/ 1998
/ Discrepancy between definitions of learning disabilities and school practices : An empirical intervention
/ Journal of Learning Disabilities
31(4)
: 314~326
[journal]
Parker, R. I.
/ 2011
/ Combining nonoverlap and trend for single-case research : Tau-U
/ Behavior Therapy
42(2)
: 284~299
[journal]
Rakap, S.
/ 2015
/ Effect sizes as result interpretation aids in single‐subject experimental research : description and application of four nonoverlap methods
/ British Journal of Special Education
42(1)
: 11~33
[journal]
Swanson, H. L.
/ 1999
/ Reading research for students with LD : A meta-analysis of intervention outcomes
/ Journal of learning disabilities
32(6)
: 504~532
[book]
Weikart, D. P.
/ 1971
/ Relationship of curriculum, teaching, and learning in preschool education
/ Johns Hopkins University Press
[journal]
Weller, C.
/ 1979
/ Training approaches on syntactic skills of language-deviant children
/ Journal of Learning Disabilities
12
: 46~55