A Study on Application of Restorative justice to Serious Crimes (중한 범죄에 대한 회복적 사법 적용 방안 연구)

MoonKwi KIM (김문귀); Kim Yong-Seok (김용석)

A Study on Application of Restorative justice to Serious Crimes

Legal Theory & Practice Review
Abbr : LTPR
2023, 11(3), pp.261-285
Publisher : The Korea Society for Legal Theory and Practice Inc.
Research Area : Social Science > Law
Received : July 30, 2023
Accepted : August 25, 2023
Published : August 31, 2023

MoonKwi KIM ¹, Kim Yong-Seok ²

¹호서대학교
²Texas A&M University 사학․정치학․철학학부 교수

Accredited

ABSTRACT

In most countries, restorative justice programs apply primarily to non-hazardous cases, relatively minor crimes such as property crimes and petty violent crimes, and are cautious about serious crimes. However, the more severe the crime, the greater the need for recovery of the victim's material and mental damage, so restorative intervention becomes more important. Indeed, in countries such as Canada, Belgium and France, restorative justice programs such as post-sentence restorative meetings and support and accountability circles are applied even to serious crimes such as sexual assault and murder. In this study, institutional, legislative, and practical measures are proposed to apply restorative justice programs or systems to serious crimes such as sex crimes and murder in Korea, and ultimately, restorative justice expands its existing criminal justice system. We tried to suggest a way to fully integrate and develop.

KEYWORDS

Restorative justice, Scope of restorative justice, Serious crimes, Post-sentential restorative encounters, Circles of support and accountability

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 김문귀 / 2015 / Action Plan and Challenges of Restorative Justice about Juvenile Delinquancy at the Police Stage / 한국치안행정논집 / 한국치안행정학회 12(2) : 1~22

[book] 김문귀 / 2016 / 회복적 경찰활동(역서) / 경찰대학출판부

[journal] 김문귀 / 2017 / A Study on the Mediation in Criminal Matters at the Police Level in Treating the Adult Cases / 법학연구 / 한국법학회 17(3) : 227~264

[journal] 김문귀 / 2018 / A Study on penal mediation in matters of environmental crimes in France / 법학연구 / 한국법학회 18(4) : 143~174

[journal] 김문귀 / 2019 / The Case Study on the Application of Restorative Justice in Sexual Assault Offenders - focused on Circles of Support and Accountability - / 법이론실무연구 / 사단법인 한국법이론실무학회 7(2) : 203~225

[journal] 김문귀 / 2020 / The Recent Tendencies and Perspective of French Restorative Justice Systems / 한국경찰연구 / 한국경찰연구학회 19(4) : 21~46

[report] 김문귀 / 2019 / 현장 경찰관의 회복적 경찰활동 방안 연구 / 경찰청

[report] 김선혜 / 2019 / 회복적 경찰활동 실천모델(案) / 경찰청

[report] 김은경 / 2008 / 회복적 소년 사법 실천모델의 효과성 연구 / 한국형사정책연구원

[book] 노성훈 / 2020 / 폴리스 트랜드 / 박영사

[report] 이원상 / 2009 / 형사화해조정제도 도입에 적합한 입법방식 / 한국형사정책연구원

[report] 이진국 / 2006 / 형사사법체계상 회복적 사법이념의 실천방안 / 한국형사정책연구원

[journal] 이호중 / 2007 / Restorative Justice in Korean Criminal Justice System - Past, Present, and Future / 형사법연구 / 한국형사법학회 19(3-하) : 297~334

[journal] 장다혜 / 2013 / 성폭력과 회복적 사법 / 젠더리뷰 / 한국여성정책연구원 2013(여름) : 23~34

[book] Aertsen(I.) / 2004 / Renouer les liens sociaux. Médiation et justice réparatrice en Europe / Ed. du Conseil de l’Europe

[journal] Camo(T.V.) / 2011 / WEMMERS(J.-A.), La justice réparatrice et les crimes graves / Criminologie 44(2) : 171~198

[book] Cario(R.) / 2012 / Justice restaurative. Principes et promesses, Coll. Traité de sciences criminelles, vol. 8 / Ed. L’Harmattan

[book] Dussich(J. P L.) / 2010 / The promise of restorative justice: Newapproaches for criminal justice and beyond / Lynne Rienner pub

[book] Goulet(J.J.) / 2010 / La justice restaurative. Une utopie qui marche ?, Coll. Controverses / Ed. L’Harmattan : 63~68

[book] Hadley(M.L.) / 2001 / The Spiritual Roots of Restorative Justice / State University of New York Press

[web] HÖING(M.) / 2011 / European Handbook of COSA(Circles of Support and Accounatability), Circles Europe: Together for Safety, Union Européenne, Daphne III / www.cep-probation.org

[book] Johnstone(G.) / 2007 / Handbook of Restorative Justice / Willan pub : 5~23

[thesis] Kim(M.K) / 2015 / Essai sur la justice restaurative illustré par les exemples de la France et de la Corée du Sud / Université de Montpellier

[web] / 2018 / Manuel sur les programmes de justice réparatrice, Coll. Série de manuels sur la réforme de la justice pénale, multigraph / www.unodc.org

[journal] Peters(T.) / 1999 / Approche restaurative des crimes et des délits en Belgique / Arch. Pol. Crim 21 : 161~179

[book] Pignoux(N.) / 2008 / La réparation des victimes d’infractions pénales, coll. Sciences criminelles / L’Harmattan

[book] Pranis(K.) / 2007 / Handbook of Restorative Justice / Willan pub. : 59~74

[book] Redekop(P.) / 2008 / Changing paradigms. Punishment and restorative discipline / Herald Press

[journal] Rossi(C.) / 2012 / Le modèle québécois des rencontres détenus-victimes, in Les cahiers de la justice / Revue semestrielle de l’E.N.M / Ed. Dalloz (2) : 107~126

[other] Service correctionnel Canada / 2002 / Cercles de soutien et de responsabilité : guide àl’intention des candidats bénévoles, Manuel de formation 2002

[other] Shantz(D.) / 2008 / Traitement des délinquants et des victimes d’actes criminels, in Petit manuel de justice réparatrice / Pub. Sécurité publique Canada : 23~34

[book] Walgrave(L.) / 2007 / Handbook of Restorative Justice / Willan pub : 559~579

[report] Wilson(R.J.) / 2005 / Cercles de soutien et de responsabilité : évaluation du projet pilote dans le Centre-sud ontarien / Service correctionnel du Canada

[report] Wilson(R.J.) / 2008 / Cercles de soutien et de responsabilité : Reproduction àl’échelle nationale des résultats obtenus / Service correctionnel du Canada

[journal] Wilson(R.J.) / 2007 / Circles of Support & Accountability: Engaging community volunteers in the management of high-risk sexual offenders / Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 46

[journal] Wilson(R.J.) / 2007 / Evaluating the effectiveness of professionally- facilitated volunteerism in the community-based management of high-risk sexual offenders--Effects on participants and stakeholders / Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 46

[book] Zehr(H.) / 2002 / The little book of restorative justice / Good Books Pub

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Legal Theory & Practice Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.03