Cultural Consensus Analysis: A Study of Research Method (문화합의분석: 새로운 조사방법에 대한 연구)

Shim, Jae-Myung (심재명)

Cultural Consensus Analysis: A Study of Research Method

Journal of Tourism Sciences
Abbr : JTS
2007, 31(1), pp.139-160
Publisher : The Tourism Sciences Society Of Korea
Research Area : Social Science > Tourism

Shim, Jae-Myung ¹

¹동국대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Developed in the field of cultural anthropology, the Cultural Consensus Analysis represents both theory and research method. While it was first developed to deal with the problem of intracultural variance in cultural studies, the key idea of the cultural consensus is that agreement between individuals is a function of their shared knowledge, and therefore the latter can be inferred from the former. ANTHROPAC is the most widely used software program for consensus analysis,and using ANTHROPAC,consensus analysis procduces three resutls; it tests whether there is consensus on the given subject among the respondents, estimates each respondent's cultural knowledge, and also estimates culturally defined true knowledge based on consensus. A case study is presented to illustrate how the method works. Cultural consensus has been extensively used in the field of anthropology and it will make a useful tool in studies of tourism too.핵심용어(Keywords): 문화적 합의(cultural consensus analysis), 응답자의 지식수준(knowledge score), 문화적으로 정의된 올바른 지식(culturally defined true knowledge), 공유된 지식(shared knowledge), ANTHROPAC.

KEYWORDS

no data found.

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 이훈 / 2006 / The Structure System Model of Lived Festival Experience. / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(1) : 29~46

[book] 한상복 / 1985 / 문화인류학 개론 / 서울대학교 출판부

[book] Babbie, E. / 1989 / The practice of social research / A Division of Wadsworth, Inc

[book] Bernard, H. R. / 1994 / Research methods in anthropology: qualitative and quantitative approaches / Sage Publications

[book] Borgatti, S. P. / 1992 / ANTHROPAC 4.0 / Analytic Technologies

[journal] Boster, J. S. / 1986 / Exchange of varieties and information between Aguaruna manioc cultivators / American Anthropologist 88 : 428~436

[book] Caplow, T. / 1954 / The Sociology of Work / McGraw-Hill

[book] Caulkins, D. / 1998 / Consensus analysis: do Scottish business advisors agree on models of success?, In Using methods in the field: A practical introduction and casebook / Altamira Press : 179~195

[journal] Caulkins, D. / 2001 / Consensus clines, and edges in Celtic cultures / Cross-Cultural Research 35 : 109~126

[journal] Chick, E. G. / 1981 / Concept and behavior in a Tlaxcalan Cargo Hierarchy / Ethnology 20 : 217~228

[journal] Coalter, F. / 1997 / Leisure sciences and leisure studies : Different concept, same crisis? / Leisure Sciences 19 : 255~268

[journal] D'Andrade, R. G. / 1981 / The cultural part of cognition / Cognitive Science 5 : 179~195

[journal] Dressler, W. W. / 1996 / Culture and blood pressure : using consensus analysis to create a measurement / Cultural Anthropology Met 8 : 6~8

[book] Dressler, W. W. / 2004 / Cognitive anthropology, In The Sage Encylcopedia of Social Science Research Methods / Sage : 139~140

[book] Fleisher, S. M. / 1998 / Freelisting: management at a women’s federal prison camp, In Using methods in the field: A practical introduction and casebook / Altamira Press : 69~84

[book] Garcia, J. G. / 1998 / Consensus analysis: High blood pressure in a Mexican Barrio, In Using Methods in the Field: A Practical Introduction and Casebook / Altamira Press : 197~210

[book] Handwerker, W. P. / 1998 / Consensus analysis: sampling frames for valid, generalizable research findings, In Using Methods in the Field: A Practical Introduction and Casebook / Altamira Press : 165~178

[journal] Handwerker, W. P. / 2002 / The construct validity of cultures: Cultural diversity, culture theory, and a method for ethnography / American Anthropologist 104 : 106~122

[book] Keesing, F. M. / 1958 / Cultural Anthropology / Holt Rinehart Winston

[book] Mayo, E. J. / 1981 / The Psychology of Leisure Travel / CBI Publishing Inc

[other] Meyersohn, R. / 1972 / International selective bibliography on leisure: Part one: U.S.A. (1966-1972)

[journal] Pelto, P. J. / 1975 / Intra-cultural diversity: some theoretical issues / American Ethnologist 2 : 1~18

[book] Roberts, J. M. / 1964 / The self-management of cultures, In Explorations in cultural anthropology / McGraw-Hill : 433~454

[journal] Romney, A. K. / 1986 / Culture as consensus : A theory of culture and informant accuracy / American Anthropologists 88 : 313~338

[thesis] Shim, J. M. / 2004 / The Evolution of Leisure Studies in North America and South Korea: A Study of Cultural Consensus / 박사 / Pennsylvania State University

[journal] Trosset, C. / 2001 / Triangulation and confirmation in the study of Welsh concepts of personhood / Journal of Anthropological Research 57 : 61~81

[book] Weller, S. C. / 1988 / Systematic Data Collection / Sage

[book] Wonnacott & Wonnacott / 1990 / Introductory Statistics for Business and Economics / Wiley

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Tourism Sciences 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 2.7