KJCKorea
Journal Central

@article{ART001522244},
author={Cha Sukbin},
title={An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method},
journal={Journal of Tourism Sciences},
issn={1226-0533},
year={2011},
volume={35},
number={1},
pages={13-31}

TY - JOUR
AU - Cha Sukbin
TI - An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method
JO - Journal of Tourism Sciences
PY - 2011
VL - 35
IS - 1
PB - The Tourism Sciences Society Of Korea
SP - 13
EP - 31
SN - 1226-0533
AB - This study was to identify the dimensions that reviewers consider impor- tant when they review and evaluate journal papers. Data were collected at several tourism academic conferences from 137 people who had experiences on journal paper review. Results revealed that in their review process, the respondents considered several criteria to be important in the following orders: research originality, clarity of research objective, consistency between research objective and research findings, and interpretation and discussion. In contrast, in terms of paper evaluation, the respondents considered research design, research findings to be more important than research topic, and literature review. Regarding the final evaluation method of papers, the respondents preferred reviewing each criteria with different weight to reviewing the criteria with same weight. They also preferred deciding the final evaluation based not on the point system of journals but on their own judgement.
KW - Review criteria;Tourism-related journals;Research evaluation
DO -
UR -
ER -

Cha Sukbin. (2011). An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method. Journal of Tourism Sciences, 35(1), 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. 2011, "An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method", Journal of Tourism Sciences, vol.35, no.1 pp.13-31.

Cha Sukbin "An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method" Journal of Tourism Sciences 35.1 pp.13-31 (2011) : 13.

Cha Sukbin. An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method. 2011; 35(1), 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. "An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method" Journal of Tourism Sciences 35, no.1 (2011) : 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method. Journal of Tourism Sciences, 35(1), 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method. Journal of Tourism Sciences. 2011; 35(1) 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method. 2011; 35(1), 13-31.

Cha Sukbin. "An Analysis of Tourism-related Journal Reviewers' Paper Review Criteria and their Preference toward Paper Evaluation Method" Journal of Tourism Sciences 35, no.1 (2011) : 13-31.