An Exploratory Study Towards Developing a Three-Dimensional Model of Evaluation for Multiple Festivals in Local Communities (지역사회의 ‘삼차원 다(多)축제 평가 모형’ 개발을 위한탐색적 연구 - 강화도의 다(多)축제 통폐합 사례연구를 중심으로 - )

Hwang Soo Young (황수영)

An Exploratory Study Towards Developing a Three-Dimensional Model of Evaluation for Multiple Festivals in Local Communities

Journal of Tourism Sciences
Abbr : JTS
2012, 36(10), pp.193-214
Publisher : The Tourism Sciences Society Of Korea
Research Area : Social Science > Tourism

Hwang Soo Young ¹

¹안양대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Local communities are increasingly exerting their efforts to attract many tourists through events such as festivals to cope with the changing leisure environment, and the current trend is to gradually increase the size of such events. However, in practice, within the academic field, there has only been research on the level of satisfaction and market segmentation with respect to festivals from the point of view of tourists or local residents. As such, there has yet to be development of a model that can be implemented to evaluate the distinct results of each local festival from the overall point of view of local residents that are socially, culturally and economically affected by the festival, the civil servants that directly operate the festivals and the tourists that participate and enjoy the benefits of the festivals. Therefore, this study identifies such issues surrounding the evaluation of local community festivals and attempts to establish a theoretical foundation for the development of a model that can be implemented to objectively evaluate the distinct results of various festivals held in each local community from the overall point of view of local residents, civil servants and tourists

KEYWORDS

Local communities, Multiple festivals, Three-dimensional evaluation model, Exploratory study

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[web] / 2012 / 경남도, 시.군 유사축제 통폐합 유도 / 거제타임즈 / http://geojetimes.co.kr

[journal] 고동완 / 2004 / The Differences of Host's and Guest's Attitudes Toward Tourism Development / 국토계획 / 대한국토·도시계획학회 39(2) : 177~188

[journal] 고승익 / 2007 / A Study on the Evaluation of Regional Festivals by Local Residents: Focused on Difference of the Attachment of Regional Community and Effect Recognition on Regional Festivals / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 31(4) : 181~202

[journal] 김근우 / 2004 / Empirical Study on the Effects of Motivation Factora on the Satisfaction of Local Festival Participants / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 27(4) : 203~218

[journal] 김석출 / 2006 / Perception, Attitude and Satisfaction of Local residents, Tourists and Civil servants toward Anmyundo Tourism Development / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 20(3) : 1~20

[journal] 김선희 / 2007 / A Comparative Study on the Satisfaction of local festival participants and tourists / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 31(1) : 407~422

[journal] 김준 / 2003 / 환경축제의 실태와 가능성 / 농촌사회 / 한국농촌사회학회 13(1) : 143~168

[web] / 2010 / 통합시 축제 통페합 제안 / 시사코리아뉴스 / http://blog.daum.net/chal379/18340591

[journal] 신용석 / 2005 / An Exploratory Research into the Framework of Stakeholders in a Local Festival: Power Struggles among Stakeholders / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 28(4) : 295~312

[web] / 2009 / 층남도 축제 통폐합 시군에 인센티브 / 서울신문 / www.seoul.co.kr

[journal] 이동수 / 2007 / A Comparative Study on the Priority Determinants of Success in Local Festivals / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 11(3) : 91~109

[journal] 이장주 / 2003 / 진도영등축제 프로그램 차별화 방안 / 문화관광연구 5(1) : 29~52

[journal] 이충기 / 2010 / Estimating the Economic Impact of Boryeong Mud Festival Using Regional Input-Output Model / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 25(5) : 83~100

[journal] 유기준 / 2012 / Stakeholders Comparison of the Baekje Cultural Tourism Festival Programs using an IPA / 관광연구논총 / 관광연구소 24(1) : 91~115

[journal] 윤병국 / 2011 / A Comparison of Residents' Perceptions toward the Saemangeum Tourism Development / 관광레저연구 / (사)한국관광레저학회 23(6) : 23~38

[journal] 이훈 / 1997 / 방문자들의 예술축제 경험과 평가분석 : 지역주민 참가자와 관광자 비교연구 / 관광연구논총 9 : 145~155

[journal] 장양례 / 2007 / A Comparative Study of Local Festival Motivation, Satisfaction, Loyalty : The case of Local residents and Visitors / 한국지역지리학회지 / 한국지역지리학회 13(6) : 724~737

[journal] 정우철 / 2010 / The Comparative Study of Stakeholder's Evaluation of Local Festival - The Case of Yakryung-Si, Daegu - / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 25(1) : 327~347

[journal] 조선배 / 2012 / The effect of Attractiveness of Local Festival on Revisit Intention - Focusing on Boryeong Mud Festival - / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 27(1) : 333~353

[report] 문화체육관광부 / 2006 / 문화관광축제종합평가계획 문화관광부 보고서

[report] 문화체육관광부 / 2011 / 2011 전국 시․도별 축제총괄표

[journal] 심상욱 / 2009 / The Impact of Servicescape on the Satisfactionand Behavioral Intention of Visitors in Festival Settings / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 33(3) : 369~390

[web] / 2008 / ‘붕어빵’ 지역축제 혈세만 축낸다: 비슷한 행사 통폐합 통해예산낭비 줄여야 / 한겨례신문 / www.kona.or.kr

[report] 한국문화관광연구원 / 2006 / 한국 지역축제 조사 평가 및 개선방안 연구

[report] 황수영 / 2009 / 강화군 축제발전 제고방안 연구보고서 / 강화군청

[journal] 황수영 / 2010 / An Empirical Study on the Impact of Tourism and Tourism Development as Perceived by Local Residents and Civil Servants - A Case on the Festivals of Ganghwa Island - / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 25(4) : 21~41

[journal] Alhemoud, A. M. / 1996 / Image of tourism attractions in Kuwait / Journal of Travel Research 34 : 76~80

[journal] Andriotis, K. / 2005 / Community groups' perceptions of and preferences for tourism development : evidence from Crete / Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research 29(1) : 67~90

[journal] Backman, K. F. / 1995 / Event tourism : An examination of motivation and activities / Festival Management & Event Tourism 3(1) : 15~24

[journal] Bryd, E. T. / 2009 / Comparisons of stakeholder perceptions of tourism impacts in rural eastern North Carolina / Tourism Management 30 : 693~703

[journal] Chew, M. S. Y. / 1998 / Culture, circles and commercials : Publicity, common knowledge and social coordination / Rationality and Society 10 : 47~75

[journal] Churchill, G. A. / 1979 / A paradigm for developing better measure of marketing constructs / Journal of Marketing Research 16 : 64~73

[journal] Concu, N. / 2012 / Conflicting preferences among tourists and residents / Tourism Management 33 : 1293~1300

[journal] Crompton, J. L. / 1997 / Motives of visitors attracting festival events / Annals of Tourism Research 24(2) : 425~439

[journal] Crouch. G. I. / 1999 / Tourism, competitiveness, and social prosperity / Journal of Business Research 44 : 137~152

[journal] Delamere, T. / 2001 / Development of a scale to measure resident attitudes toward the social impacts of community festivals, PartⅠ : Item generation and purification of the measure / Event Management 7 : 11~24

[book] DeVellis, R. F. / 1991 / Scale development: Theory and applications, In In Applied social research method series, Vol. 26 / Sage

[journal] Enright, M. J. / 2004 / Tourism destination competitiveness : a quantitative approach / Tourism Management 25 : 777~788

[journal] Formica, S. / 1998 / The effects of group membership and motivation on attendance: An international festival case / Tourism Analysis 3(3-4) : 197~207

[journal] Formica, S. / 1996 / A market segmentation of festival visitors : Umbra Jass Festival in Italy / Festival Management & Event Tourism 3(4) : 175~182

[journal] Gartner, W. C. / 1983 / Economic impact of an annual tourism industry exposition / Annals of Tourism Research 10(2) : 199~212

[book] Getz, D. / 1997 / Event management and event tourism / Cognizant Communication

[journal] Getz, D. / 2002 / Why festival fails / Event Management 7(4) : 209~219

[journal] Grappi, S. / 2011 / The role of social identification and hedonism in affecting tourist re-patronizing behaviors : The case of an Italian Festival / Tourism Management 32 : 1128~1140

[journal] Kavallinis, I. / 1994 / The environmental impact of tourism : whose responsibility is it anyway? The case study of Mykonos / Journal of Travel Research 33(2) : 26~32

[journal] Lankford, S. V. / 1994 / Attitudes and perceptions toward tourism and rural regional development / Journal of Travel Research 32(3) : 35~43

[journal] Lankford, S. V. / 1994 / Developing a tourism impact attitude sacle / Annals of Tourism Research 21(1) : 121~139

[journal] Liu, J. C. / 1987 / Resident perceptions of the environmental impact of tourism / Annals of Tourism Research 14 : 17~37

[journal] Liu, J. C. / 1986 / Resident attitudes touward tourism impacts in Hawaii / Annals of Tourism Research 14 : 17~37

[journal] Murphy, P. E. / 1983 / Perceptions and attitudes of decision making groups in tourism centers / Journal of Travel Research 21(3) : 8~22

[journal] Nicholson, R. E. / 2001 / Why do people attend events : A comparative apeople of visitor motivation at four south island events / Journal of Travel Research 39 : 449~460

[journal] Puczko, L. / 2000 / Tourist and resident perceptions of the physical impacts of tourism at Lake Balaton, Hungary : issues for sustainable tourism management / Journal of Sustainable Tourism 8(6) : 458~477

[journal] Rao, V. / 2001 / Celebrations as social investments : Festival expenditures, unit price variation and social status in rural India / The Journal of Development Studies 38(1) : 71~97

[journal] Royo-Vela, M / 2009 / Reral-cultural excursion conceptualization : A local tourism marketing management model based on tourist destination image measurement / Tourism Management 30 : 419~428

[journal] Thrane, C. / 2002 / Jazz festival visitors and their expenditures : Linking spending patterns to musical interest / Journal of Travel Research 40 : 281~286

[book] Uysal, M. / 1991 / An examination of event tourism motivations and activities, In New horizons in tourism and hospitality education, training and research: Conference proceedings / University of Calgary : 203~218

[journal] Uysal, M. / 1993 / An examination of event motivations : A case study / Festival Management & Event Tourism 1(1) : 5~10

[journal] Uysal, M. / 1994 / Assessment of economic impacts : Festivals and special events / Festival Management & Event Tourism 2(1) : 3~10

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Tourism Sciences 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 2.7