Asia Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.86
-
pISSN : 2234-0386
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/asiareview
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Characteristics of the Concept of Mega-Asia Viewed through a Comparison with World-Systems Analysis: Coexistence of a Theoretical System and a Methodological Tool
- Asia Review
- Abbr : SNUACAR
- 2022, 12(2), pp.171~206
- Publisher : 아시아연구소
- Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
- Received : January 6, 2022
- Accepted : July 29, 2022
- Published : August 31, 2022
1한경대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study is to explore the identity of Mega-Asia. MegaAsia is a theoretical concept that envisions a new and integrated (or connected) Asia, which has recently been discussed by scholars. Given that Mega-Asia has theoretical or methodological strengths while distinguishing itself from existing Asian discourse, this theoretical idea of Mega-Asia may be used continuously in the future. Despite the importance and timeliness of the Mega-Asia concept, several questions arise around Mega-Asia. Among these questions, this study attempts to answer the question of what identity Mega-Asia has. To this end, we assume that Mega Asia has the characteristics of both a theoretical system and methodological tool, and then we bring an idea of Immanuel Wallerstein’s world-systems analysis, which encompasses the characteristics of the theoretical system and methodological tool. By explaining world-systems analysis understood as a theoretical system and a methodological tool, we try to explore the theoretical and methodological features embedded in the concept of Mega-Asia. Although we show some the theoretical and methodological features of the Mega-Asia concept, we will clarify that this study is preliminary research in revealing the identity of Mega Asia.
Statistics
-
243 Viewed
-
142 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[book]
김경일
/ 1998
/ 지역연구의 역사와 이론
/ 문화과학사
[journal]
김숙진
/ 2016
/
Assemblage and Its Geographical Implication
/ 대한지리학회지
/ 대한지리학회
51(3)
: 311~326
[confproc]
김종호
/ 2021
/ 남중국해 화교화인 네트워크 속 사람, 자본, 물자의 이동
/ 서울대 아시아연구소 HK+ 메가아시아 사업단, 해양과 메가아시아 2차 워크샵
[book]
도오루, 야노
/ 지역연구의 역사와 이론
/ 문화과학사
[journal]
유성희
/ 2011
/
Understanding of M. Weber's theory of state based on Ideal type
/ 인문논총
/ 인문과학연구소
27
: 5~51
[journal]
신범식
/ 2021
/
Emerging Mega-Asia: History and Concept
/ 아시아리뷰
/ 아시아연구소
11(2)
: 3~34
[book]
에노모토 와타루
/ 2012
/ 해역아시아사 연구입문
/ 민속원
: 30~38
[confproc]
유성희
/ 2021
/ 19세기 태평양 세력의 등장과 메가아시아의 부상
/ 서울대학교 아시아연구소 HK+ 메가아시아 사업단, 해양과 메가아시아 2차 워크숍
[thesis]
윤상우
/ 2002
/ 동아시아 발전국가의 위기와 재편 : 한국과 대만 비교연구
/ 박사
/ 고려대학교 대학원
[journal]
윤종석
/ 2021
/
‘East Asia’ as a ‘Region’: Implications of a Mega-Asian Perspective to East Asia
/ 아시아리뷰
/ 아시아연구소
11(2)
: 57~95
[book]
월러스틴, 이매뉴얼
/ 1993
/ 역사적 자본주의/자본주의 문명
/ 창비
[book]
월러스틴
/ 1994
/ 사회과학으로부터의 탈피
/ 창비
[journal]
월러스틴, 이매뉴얼
/ 2001
/ 근대세계체제 1: 자본주의적 농업과 16세기 유럽 세계경제의 기원
/ 까치
[journal]
이광근
/ 2020
/
The Past and Present of the World-Systems Analysis: A Critical Reconstitution of Immanuel Wallerstein's Intellectual Itinerary
/ 현상과 인식
/ 한국인문사회과학회
44(1)
: 181~228
[book]
임현진
/ 2016
/ 아시아의 부상: 문명의 전환인가
/ 서울대학교출판문화원
[book]
임현진
/ 2021
/ 글로벌 아시아: 자본주의 발전과 포스트 발전국가의 미래
/ 서울대학교출판문화원
[journal]
임현진
/ 2020
/
21st Century Civilizational Crisis and the World-System Analysis: Immanuel Wallerstein’s Comparative-Historical Perspective
/ 아시아리뷰
/ 아시아연구소
10(2)
: 3~35
[book]
자오팅양
/ 2022
/ 천하: 세계와 미래에 대한 중국의 철학
/ 이음
[book]
챠크라바티, 디페시
/ 2014
/ 유럽을 지방화하기: 포스트 식민 사상과 역사적 차이
/ 그린비
[book]
하버마스, 위르겐
/ 2006
/ 의사소통행위이론 2
/ 나남
[book]
홉킨즈, 테렌스 K
/ 2011
/ 이행의 시대: 세계체제의 궤적, 1945-2025
/ 창작과 비평사
: 11~23
[book]
Abu-Luhod, Janet L
/ 1989
/ Before European Hegemony: The World System A.D. 1250-1350
/ Oxford University Press
: 1250~1350
[journal]
Anievas, Alexander
/ 2017
/ Why Europe? Anti-Eurocentric Theory, History, and the Rise of Capitalism
/ Spectrum: Journal of Global Studies
8(1)
: 70~98
[journal]
Aronowitz, Stanley
/ 1981
/ A Metatheoretical Critique of Immanuel Wallerstein’s the Modern World System
/ Theory and Society
10(4)
: 503~520
[book]
Arrighi, Giovanni
/ 2007
/ Adam Smith in Beijing: Lineages of the 21st Century
/ Verso
[book]
Arrighi, Giovanni
/ 2003
/ The Resurgence of East Asia
/ Routledge
: 1~16
[web]
Asian Development Bank
/ 2021
/ Asian Economic Integration Report 2021: Making Digital Platforms Work for Asia and the Pacific
/ https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/674421/asian-economicintegration-report-2021.pdf
[journal]
Babones, Salvatore
/ 2015
/ What is World-systems Analysis? Distinguishing Theory from Perspective
/ Thesis Eleven
127(1)
: 3~20
[book]
Bloch, Ernst
/ 1991
/ Heritage of Our Times
/ University of California Press
[book]
Braudel, Fernand
/ 1982
/ Civilization and Capitalism, 15-18th Century: The Wheels of Commerce, Volume II
/ Harper & Row
[book]
Broeze, Frank
/ 1989
/ Brides of the Sea: Port Cities of Asia From the 16th-20th Centuries
/ University of Hawaii Press
: 1~28
[book]
Buzan, Barry
/ 2003
/ Regions and Powers: The Structure of International Security
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Cameron, Rondo
/ 1973
/ The Logistics of European Economic Growth: A Note on Historical Periodization
/ Journal of European Economic History
2(1)
: 145~148
[journal]
Chang, Kyung-Sup
/ 2014
/ Asianization of Asia: Asia’s Integrative Ascendance through a European Aperture
/ European Societies
16(3)
: 337~342
[book]
Chase-Dunn, Christopher
/ 1997
/ The Theoretical Evolution of International Political Economy
/ Oxford University Press
: 144~157
[book]
Chen, Kuan-Hsing
/ 2010
/ Asia as Method: Toward Deimperialization
/ Duke University Press
[book]
Chen, Song-Chuan
/ 2017
/ Merchants of War and Peace: British Knowledge of China in the Making of the Opium War
/ Hong Kong University Press
[journal]
Cumings, Bruce
/ 1984
/ The Origins and Development of the Northeast Asian Political Economy: Industrial Sectors, Product Cycles, and Political Consequences
/ International Organizations
38(1)
: 1~40
[journal]
Destradi, Sandra
/ 2010
/ Regional Powers and Their Strategies: Empire, Hegemony, and Leadership
/ Review of International Studies
36(4)
: 903~930
[journal]
Duara, Presenjit
/ 2001
/ The Disciourse of Civilization and Pan-Asianism
/ Journal of World History
12(1)
: 99~130
[journal]
Duara, Presenjit
/ 2010
/ Asia Redux: Conceptualizing a Region for Our Times
/ The Journal of Asian Studies
69(4)
: 963~983
[journal]
Duara, Presenjit
/ 2014
/ The Discourse of Civilization and Pan-Asianism
/ Journal of World History
12(1)
: 99~130
[book]
Emmott, Bill
/ 2009
/ Rivals: How the Power Struggle between China, India, and Japan Will Shape Our Next Decade
/ Penguin Books
[book]
Fenton, William Nelson
/ 1947
/ Area Studies in American Universities
/ American Council on Education
[journal]
Foster-Carter, Aidan
/ 1978
/ The Modes of Production Controversy
/ New Left Review
107
: 47~77
[book]
Frey, Marc
/ 2016
/ Asianims: Regionalist Interactions and Asian Integration
/ NUS Press
[journal]
Funabashi, Yoichi
/ 1993
/ The Asianization of Asia
/ Foreign Affairs
72(5)
: 75~85
[journal]
Goldstone, Jack A
/ 1996
/ Gender, Work, and Culture: Why the Industrial Revolution Came Early to England But Late to China
/ Sociological Perspective
39(1)
: 1~21
[journal]
Hopkins, Terence K
/ 1977
/ Patterns of Development of the Modern World-system
/ Review
1(2)
: 11~45
[journal]
Kimmel, Michael
/ 1982
/ Review on the Modern World System, Volume II
/ Theory and Society
11(2)
: 244~251
[book]
Kondratieff, Nikolai
/ 1984
/ The Long Wave Cycle
/ Richardson & Snyder
[journal]
Krugman, Paul
/ 1994
/ The Myth of Asia’s Miracle
/ Foreign Affairs
73(6)
: 62~78
[journal]
Kurlantzick, Joshua
/ 2011
/ The Asian Century? No Quite Yet
/ Current History
110(732)
: 26~31
[journal]
Landes, Davis S
/ 2006
/ Why Euorpe and the West? Why not China
/ The Journal of Economic Perspective
20
: 3~22
[book]
Mahbubani, Kishore
/ 2008
/ The New Asian Hemisphere: The Irresistible Shift of Global Power to the East
/ Public Affairs
[journal]
Martin, William G
/ 1994
/ The World-Systems Perspective in Perspective: Assessing the Attempt to Move Beyond Nineteenth-Century Eurocentric Conceptions
/ Review
17(2)
: 145~185
[book]
Marx, Karl
/ 1973
/ Grundrisse
/ Penguin Books
[book]
Marx, Karl
/ 1983
/ Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, Volume 1
/ International Publishers
[journal]
McMichael, Philip
/ 1990
/ Incorporating Comparison within a World Historical Perspective: An Alternative Comparative Method
/ American Sociological Review
55(3)
: 385~397
[journal]
McMichael, Philip
/ 2000
/ World-Systems Analysis, Globalization, and Incorporating comparison
/ Journal of World-Systems Research
VI(3)
: 68~99
[book]
Mearsheimer, John
/ 2001
/ The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
/ W. W. Norton & Company
[journal]
Morgenthau, Hans J
/ 1952
/ Area Studies and the Study of International Relations
/ International Social Science Bulletin
4(4)
: 647~655
[book]
Mulakala, Anthea
/ 2021
/ The Palgrave Handbook of Development Cooperation for Achieving the 2030Agenda
/ Palgrave Macmillan
: 519~541
[book]
Myers, David J
/ 1991
/ Regional Hegemons: Threat Perception and Strategic Response
/ Boulder, CO
: 1~29
[book]
Nayyar, Deepak
/ 2019
/ Resurgent Asia: Diversity in Development
/ Oxford University Press
[book]
Parsons, Talcott
/ 1966
/ Societies: Evolutionary And Comparative Perspective
/ Prentice-Hall
[book]
Parsons, Talcott
/ 1991
/ Talcott Parsons: The Early Essays
/ The University of Chicago Press
: 109~122
[web]
Pei, Minxin
/ 2009
/ Think Again: Asia’s Rise
/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/06/21/think-again-asias-rise/
[journal]
Prys, Miriam
/ 2010
/ Hegemony, Domination, Detachment: Differences in Regional Powerhood
/ International Studies Review
12(4)
: 479~504
[journal]
Research Working Group on Cyclical Rhythms and Secular Trends
/ 1979
/ Cyclical Rhythms an Secular Trends of the Capitalist World-Economy: Some Premises
/ Review
2(4)
: 483~500
[journal]
류성희
/ 2019
/
The Critical Appraisal of Existing Comparison Methods: Bringing the Connected Histories into Chinese Stagnation Studies
/ Journal of Asian Sociology
/ 사회발전연구소
48(2)
: 231~261
[journal]
유성희
/ 2020
/
Two Theoretical Resources for the Nineteenth Century China’s Incorporation Process : A Strategy for Understanding China’s Capitalist Transition
/ 한국사회학
/ 한국사회학회
54(2)
: 193~226
[journal]
Ru, Sung Hee
/ 2021
/ Conceptualizing China’s Tea History in the 19th Century: Incorporation into the Capitalist World-Economy
/ Journal of Agrarian Change
21(5)
: 1~19
[book]
Saaler, Sven
/ 2011
/ Pan-Asianism: A Documentary History, Volume 1
/ Rowan & Littlefield
[book]
Samaddar, Ranabir
/ 1999
/ The Marginal Nation: Transborder Migration from Bangladesh to India
/ Sage
[journal]
Skocpol, Theda
/ 1977
/ Wallerstein’s World Capitalist System: A Theoretical and Historical Critique
/ American Journal of Sociology
82(5)
: 1075~1090
[thesis]
Smith, Craig Anthony
/ 1924
/ Constructing Chinese Asianism: Intellectual Writings on East Asian Regionalism (1896-1924)
/ Ph.D
/ The University of British Columbia
[journal]
Szpilman, Christopher W
/ 2011
/ Pan-Asanism as an Ideal of Asian Identity and Solidarity
/ The Asia-Pacific Journal
9(17)
: 1~30
[book]
Tilly, Charles
/ 1990
/ Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990-1990
/ Oxford:Basil Blackwell
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1974
/ The Modern World-system I: Capitalist Agricutlure and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century
/ Academic Press
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1976
/ The Modern World-System
/ Academic Press
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1980
/ The Modern World-System II
/ University of California Press
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1989
/ The Modern World-System III
/ Academic Press
[journal]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1992
/ Geopolitical Strategies of the US in a Post-American World
/ Humboldt Journal of Social Relations
XVIII(1)
: 217~233
[journal]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 1998
/ The Rise and Future Demise of World-Systems Analysis
/ Review
21(1)
: 103~112
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 2011
/ The Modern World-System IV
/ University of California Press
[book]
Wallerstein, Immanuel
/ 2012
/ Routledge Handbook of World-Systems Analysis
/ Routledge
: 515~521
[book]
Weber, Max
/ 1922
/ Gesammelte Aufsätze Zur Wissenschaftslehre
/ J.C.B. Mohr
[book]
Weiss, Linda
/ 1995
/ States and Economic Development: A Comparative Historical Analysis
/ Polity Press
[journal]
Zhang Kyung-sup
/ 2014
/ Asianization of Asia: Asia’s Integrative Ascendence through a European Aperture
/ European Societies
16(3)
: 337~342
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.