Reading Fluency of Elementary Students with and without Reading Disabilities : Reading Developmental Patterns and Error Patterns (초등학교 읽기장애 학생과 일반 학생의 읽기 유창성 특성 및 오류 유형 비교 연구 )

Ae-Hwa Kim (김애화); 박성희

Reading Fluency of Elementary Students with and without Reading Disabilities : Reading Developmental Patterns and Error Patterns

Journal of Special Education: Theory and Practice
Abbr : JSPED
2010, 11(4), pp.323-344
Publisher : Research Institute of the Korea Special Education
Research Area : Social Science > Education

Ae-Hwa Kim ¹, 박성희 ¹

¹단국대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

The purpose of this study was to compare the reading fluency(reading developmental patterns and error patterns) of elementary students with and without reading disabilities. A total of 55 elementary students with and without reading disabilities participated in reading fluency tests. Developmental patterns of reading fluency across grades and the types of errors were analyzed. Major results are summed up as follows. First, reading fluency results showed significant differences in all the two tests. Second, as the result of analyzing the errors from word-level perspective, the replacement errors appeared most frequently. Third, as the result of analyzing the errors from word-level perspective, students tended to replace words with words that had another meaning rather than changing it into nonwords. Forth, as for the rates of errors by phonological change rules, students with reading disabilities were much higher than students without reading disabilities. Fifth, as the result of analyzing the errors from text-level perspective, the second-grade students with and without reading disabilities showed the more errors that did not make sense than the errors that retained the meaning of the sentence. However, the fourth-grader students with and without reading disabilities showed more errors that retained the meaning of the sentence than the errors that did not make sense. And based on such results, the characteristics of reading fluency and similarities and differences in both groups were discussed.

KEYWORDS

reading fluency, developmental pattern, error pattern, students with reading disabilities

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] 곽금주 / 2001 / 한국 웩슬러 아동지능검사 III(Korean-Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III: K-WISC-III) / 도서출판 특수교육

[book] 김광해 / 2003 / 등급별 국어교육용 어휘 / 박이정

[journal] 김길순 / 2009 / Effects of the Rapid Automatized Naming Training on Naming Speed and Reading Fluency for Children with Learning Disabilities / 학습장애연구 / 한국학습장애학회 6(2) : 151~171

[journal] 김미경 / 2003 / A Study of Phonological Awareness and Reading Fluency in Children with Reading Disabilities / 정서·행동장애연구 / 한국정서·행동장애아교육학회 19(4) : 381~400

[journal] 김애화 / 2009 / Spelling Skills of Elementary Students in Korea: Focusing on Spelling Accuracy and Error Patterns / 초등교육연구 / 한국초등교육학회 22(4) : 85~113

[journal] 김애화 / 2010 / Reading Fluency of Elementary Students in Korea: Reading Developmental Patterns and Error Patterns / 언어청각장애연구 / 한국언어청각임상학회 15(1) : 43~55

[journal] 김애화 / 2010 / Prediction of Reading Comprehension in Elementary School Students / 언어청각장애연구 / 한국언어청각임상학회 15(3) : 357~380

[journal] 김애화 / 2009 / Word Recognition Skills of Elementary Students in Korea: Focusing on Word Recognition Accuracy, Word Recognition Fluency, and Error Patterns / 특수교육학연구 / 한국특수교육학회 44(2) : 155~183

[journal] 김애화 / 2008 / Prediction of reading skills in upper elementary students / 언어청각장애연구 / 한국언어청각임상학회 13(1) : 1~25

[book] 김윤옥 / 2001 / 수준별 교육을 위한 읽기진단검사 / 도서출판 특수교육

[journal] 김의정 / 2006 / The Effects of Research-Based Reading Instruction on the Reading Fluency and Reading Comprehension of Students with Learning Disabilities / 특수교육연구 / 국립특수교육원 13(2) : 247~274

[journal] 남기춘 / 2004 / The Effects of Korean Logical Ending Connective Affix on the Text Comprehension and Recall / 언어청각장애연구 / 한국언어청각임상학회 9(3) : 51~71

[report] 박경숙 / 2008 / 국립특수교육원 기초학력검사 / 국립특수교육원

[book] 박현숙 / 2003 / 전산화된 읽기 평가-교수 도구 / 재단법인 파라다이스 복지재단

[journal] 박현숙 / 1999 / 읽기장애의 오류 유형 분석을 통한 비공식적 평가 방법에 관한 연구 / 재활복지 3(2) : 20~39

[journal] 이일화 / 2003 / The Relationship between Reading Fluency and Reading Comprehension in Primary Grades / 교육심리연구 / 한국교육심리학회 17(4) : 239~256

[journal] 황민아 / 2003 / Sentence Comprehension of Korean Children with Specific Language Impairments / 언어청각장애연구 / 한국언어청각임상학회 8(3) : 1~21

[journal] Bear, D. / 1991 / “Learning to fasten the seat of ,y union suit without looking around”: The synchrony of literacy development / Theory Into Practice 30(3) : 148~157

[journal] Bowers, P. G. / 1991 / Naming speed deficits in reading disability: Multiple measures of a singular process / Journal of Experimental Psychology 51 : 195~219

[book] Brown, J. / 1996 / Studies in miscue analysis. in: An annotated biblilgraphy / International Reading Association

[journal] Cutting, L. / 2006 / Prediction of reading comprehension: relative contributions of word recognition, language proficiency, and other cognitive skills can depend on how comprehension is measured / Scientific Studies of Reading 10 : 277~299

[journal] Daly, E. J. / 1994 / A comparison of three interventions for increasing oral reading performance: Application of the instructional hierarchy / Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 27 : 459~469

[journal] Deno, L. S. / 1985 / Curriculum-based measurement: The emerging alternative / Exceptional Children 52 : 219~232

[journal] Deno, S. L. / 2003 / Developments in curriculum-based measurement / The Journal of Special Education 374(3) : 184~192

[journal] Ellis, N. C. / 2001 / Why learning to read is easier in Welsh than in English: Orthographic transparency effect evidenced with frequency-matched tests / Applied Psycholinguistics 22 : 571~599

[book] Fletcher, J. M. / 2002 / Classification of learning disabilities: An Evidenced-based evaluation. in: Identification of learning disabilities: Research to pratice / Erlbaum : 185~250

[journal] Fuchs, L. S. / 2001 / Oral reading fluency as an indicator of reading competence: A theoretical, empirical, and historical analysis / Scientific Studies of Reading 5(3) : 239~256

[web] Good, R. H. / Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills / Institute for the Development of Education Achievement / http://dibels.uoregon.edu/

[journal] Goodman, K. S. / 1969 / Analysis of oral reading miscues / Applied psycholinguistics 5(1) : 9~30

[book] Goodman, K. S. / 1973 / Miscue analysis. in: Applications to reading instruction / National Council of Teachers of English

[journal] Henderson, E. H. / 1986 / A developmental perspective of formal spelling instruction through alphabet, pattern, and meaning / Elementary School Journal 86 : 305~316

[journal] Hosp, M. K. / 2005 / Using CBM as an indicator of decoding, word reading, and comprehension: Do the relations change with grade? / School Psychology Review 34(1) : 9~26

[journal] Hoxhallari, L. / 2004 / Learning to read words in Albanian: A skill easily acquired / Scientific studies of reading 8(2) : 153~166

[journal] Jenkins, J. R. / 2003 / Accuracy and fluency in list and context reading of skilled and RD groups: Absolute and relative performance levels / Learning Disabilities: Research & Practice 18 : 237~245

[journal] Lapp, D. / 1995 / Using multiple text formats to explore scientific phenomena in middle school classrooms / Reading and Writing Quarterly: Overcoming Learning Difficulties 11 : 173~186

[journal] Lyon, G. R. / 1997 / Critical conceptual and methodological considerations in reading intervention research / Journal of Learning Disabilities 30 : 578~588

[journal] Marciarille Le Vasseur, V. / 2008 / Promoting gains in reading fluency: a comparison of three approaches / Reading and Writing 21(3) : 205~230

[journal] Meyer, M. S. / 1999 / Repeated reading to enhance fluency: Old approaches and new directions / Annals of Dyslexia 49 : 283~306

[report] National Reading Panel / 2000 / Report of the national reading panel. Teaching children to read: An evidence-based assessment of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for reading instructions / Government Printing Office

[journal] Parker, R. / 1992 / Greater validity for oral reading fluency: Can miscues help? / The Journal of Special Education 25(4) : 492~503

[journal] Pflaum, S. W. / 1979 / Oral reading error correction and cloze performance / Reading World 19 : 168~178

[journal] Pflaum, S. W. / 1980 / Diagnosis of oral reading / The Reading Teacher 33 : 278~284

[book] Pikulski, J. J. / 2006 / Fluency: A developmental and language perspective. in: What research has to say about f luency instruction / International Reading Association : 70~93

[journal] Rasinski, T. / 1990 / Investigating measures of reading fluency / Educational Research Quarterly 14(3) : 37~44

[journal] Sieg / 1992 / An Evaluation of the discrepancy definition of dyslexia / Journal of Learning Disabilities 25(10) : 618~629

[journal] Snowling, M. / 1989 / A longitudinal case study of developmental phonological dyslexia / Cognitive Neuropsychology 6 : 379~401

[journal] Stanovich, K. E. / 1994 / Phenotypic performance profile of children with reading difficulties: A regression-based test of phonological-core variable- difference model / Journal of Educational Psychology 86 : 1~30

[journal] Torgesen, J. K. / 1994 / Longitudinal studies of phonological processing and reading / Journal of learning Disabilities 27 : 276~286

[book] Torgesen, J. K. / 2001 / Principles of fluency instruction in reading: Relationships with established empirical outcomes. in: Dyslexia, Fluency, and the Brain / York Press : 333~355

[journal] Wanzek, J. / 2010 / Differences in measures of high stakes reading achievement and the effects on oral reading fluency progress monitoring / Assessment for Effective Intervention 35(2) : 67~77

[journal] Weber, R. / 1968 / The study of oral reading errors: A survey of the literature / Reading Research Quarterly 4(1) : 96~119

[journal] Wolf, M. / 1999 / The “Double-Deficit Hypothesis” for the developmental dyslexias / Journal of Educational Psychology 91(3) : 1~24

[journal] Wolf, M. / 2001 / Reading fluency and its intervention / Scientific Studies of Reading 5 : 211~238

[journal] Yovanoff, P. / 2005 / Grade-level invariance of a theoretical causal structure predicting reading comprehension with vocabulary and oral reading fluency / Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice 24(3) : 4~12

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Special Education: Theory and Practice 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.96