Analysis of the Causes of the Land Compensation Disputes in Vietnam Using AHP (AHP를 이용한 베트남 토지보상 분쟁원인 분석)

Kim， Jung Sun (김정선); Park， Sang Bong (박상봉); Man， Quang Huy (만쿠앙후이); Le， Phuong Thuy (레프엉투이); Tran， Van Tuan (쩐번뚜언)

doi:10.35136/krer.29.3.5

Analysis of the Causes of the Land Compensation Disputes in Vietnam Using AHP

Korea Real Estate Review
2019, 29(3), pp.77-91
DOI : 10.35136/krer.29.3.5
Publisher : korea real estate research institute
Research Area : Social Science > Law > Law of Special Parts > Law of Real Estate
Received : June 21, 2019
Accepted : September 6, 2019
Published : September 30, 2019

Kim， Jung Sun ¹, Park， Sang Bong ², Man， Quang Huy ¹, Le， Phuong Thuy ¹, Tran， Van Tuan ¹

¹하노이대
²강남대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This study is conducted to analyze the causes of the land compensation disputes in Vietnam as well as their relative importance, and to review the relevant suggestions. For the analysis (AHP analysis), a multidimensional decision-making model is applied to specialists in the administration, policy, and practice fields. For the results of the study, in the first primary-level element analysis, compensation expertise appears to have the highest relative importance (0.443), and compensation participation, the lowest. This is inconsistent with the result of the preceding study that compensation inappropriateness is the only cause of land compensation disputes. Second, in the analysis of the relative importance of the causes of land compensation disputes based on the secondary-level elements, the relative importance of the rights protection plan (0.281), a small compensation (0.397), the presence of detailed compensation provisions (0.448), and the recovery procedure participation method (0.261) appear high. Third, in the comprehensive analysis of the secondary-level elements, the relative importance of the presence of detailed compensation provisions (0.198) appears the highest. It is expected that if the procedure/technique of the land compensation system of South Korea is introduced in Vietnam for the institutional establishment of detailed compensation provisions and compensation methods therein, it can serve as a guideline for solving the problem of land compensation disputes in Vietnam. It seems that further studies are required to investigate the causes of land compensation disputes involving those who do not receive compensation for their land, and to compare the results of such studies with the views of expert groups.

KEYWORDS

Vietnamese land compensation, Vietnamese land compensation system, land recovery system, causes of land compensation disputes, AHP analysis

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] 김병욱 / 2015 / 의사결정계층(AHP) 분석방법 / 킴스정보전략연구소

[journal] 김정선 / 2019 / The Present Status of the Vietnamese Official Land Price System and Tasks: Focusing on the Fundamental Land Price System / 감정평가학논집 / 한국감정평가학회 18(1) : 159~179

[journal] 유영명 / 2017 / A Comparative Analysis of the Quality of Life Among Local Governments in Busan through AHP / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 20(4) : 365~382

[journal] 이영수 / 2008 / A Study on the Present Situation and Problems of the Compensation System in China / 부동산학보 / 한국부동산학회 (32) : 245~261

[report] 전병서 / 2010 / 베트남 부동산 및건설법제 연구 / 법제처

[book] KOCHM / 2019 / 베트남 경제백서 2019

[journal] Al-Harbi, K. A. / 2001 / Application of the AHP in Project Management / International Journal of Project Man-agement / Association for Project Management⋅International Project Management Association 19(1) : 19~27

[journal] Beresford, M. / 2008 / Doi Moi in review: The challenges of building market socialism in Vietnam / Journal of Contemporary Asia / Taylor &Francis 38(2) : 221~243

[journal] Ding, C. / 2007 / Policy and praxis of land acquisition in China / Land Use Policy / Elsevier 24(1) : 1~13

[book] Gillespie, J. / 2014 / Narrating Land Disputes in Three Vietnamese Communities, published in Resolving Land Disputes in East Asia: Exploring the Limits of Law / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Han, S. S. / 2008 / Land Acquisition in Transitional Hanoi, Vietnam / Urban Studies / Sage 45(5-6) : 1097~1117

[journal] Ho, P. / 2017 / Who owns China's housing? Endogeneity as a lens to understand ambiguities of urban and rural property / Cities / Elsevier 65 : 66~77

[journal] Kim, A. M. / 2004 / A market without the 'right' property rights / Economics of Transition / The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development 12(2) : 275~305

[journal] Kim, A. M. / 2011 / Talking Back : The Role of Narrative in Vietnam's Recent Land Compensation Changes / Urban Studies / Sage 48(3) : 493~508

[journal] Labbé, D. / 2014 / Periurban Land Redevelopment in Vietnam under Market Socialism / Urban Studies / Sage 51(6) : 1146~1161

[journal] Lai, Y. / 2014 / Industrial land development in urban villages in China: A property rights perspective / Habitat International / Elsevier 41 : 185~194

[journal] Lootsma, F. A. / 1997 / Multicriteria Decision Analysis in a Decision Tree / European Journal of Operational Research / Elsevier 101(3) : 442~451

[journal] Nguyen, T. B. / 2017 / Collaborative development:Capturing the public value in private real estate development projects in Ho Chi Minh city, Vietnam / Cities / Elsevier 68 : 104~118

[report] Perkins, D. H. / 2009 / China's land system : Past, present and future, published in Property Rights and Land Policies / Lincoln Institute of Land Policy

[journal] Pham, H. T. / 2013 / Compensation and Resettlement Policies after Compulsory Land Acquisition for Hydropower Development in Vietnam: Policy and Practice / Land / International Association for Landscape Ecology 2(4) : 678~704

[journal] Saaty, T. L. / 1990 / How to make a Decision: The Analytic Hierarchy Process / European Journal of Operational Research / Elsevier 48(1) : 9~26

[journal] Shan, L. / 2017 / Strategies for risk management in urban–rural conflict: Two case studies of land acquisition in urbanising China / Habitat International / Elsevier 59 : 90~100

[journal] Thu, T. T. / 2011 / Consequences of the two-price system for land in the land and housing market in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam / Habitat International / Elsevier 35(1) : 30~39

[book] World Bank / 2011 / Compulsory Land Acquisition and Voluntary Land Conversion in Vietnam / World Bank

[web] 한경닷컴 / 포스트 차이나, 한국은 베트남 투자 1위 / http://www.hankyung.com

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korea Real Estate Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.56

Analysis of the Causes of the Land Compensation Disputes in Vietnam Using AHP

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Korea Real Estate Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.56

Analysis of the Causes of the Land Compensation Disputes in Vietnam Using AHP

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (25) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.